Eye for an Eye

8 Magic: The Gathering cards are named Eye for an Eye, across 8 sets released from 1993 to 2011. The newest printing is from Masters Edition IV, released 10 Jan 2011. As of 18 Oct 2026, the most valuable is Eye for an Eye 4 from Arabian Nights (Normal) at $43.64 on TCGplayer and Eye for an Eye 18 from Summer Magic / Edgar (Normal) at €500.00 on Cardmarket. The cheapest is Eye for an Eye 30 from Fifth Edition (Normal) at $0.60 on TCGplayer and the same printing (Normal) at €0.46 on Cardmarket.

Every Eye for an Eye printing with its cheapest non-foil and dearest foil TCGplayer (USD) and Cardmarket (EUR) market price and variant

Card	Set	Rarity	Released	TCGplayerUSD	CardmarketEUR
Eye for an Eye 12Masters Edition IV · rare · 10 Jan 2011	Masters Edition IV	rare	10 Jan 2011	—	—
Eye for an Eye 30Fifth Edition · rare · 24 Mar 1997	Fifth Edition	rare	24 Mar 1997	$0.60Normal	€0.46Normal
Eye for an Eye 25Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border · rare · 1 Apr 1995	Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border	rare	1 Apr 1995	—	€3.44Normal
Eye for an Eye 25Fourth Edition · rare · 1 Apr 1995	Fourth Edition	rare	1 Apr 1995	$0.81Normal	€0.53Normal
Eye for an Eye 18Summer Magic / Edgar · rare · 21 Jun 1994	Summer Magic / Edgar	rare	21 Jun 1994	—	€500.00Normal
Eye for an Eye 18Revised Edition · rare · 11 Apr 1994	Revised Edition	rare	11 Apr 1994	$1.14Normal	€0.63Normal
Eye for an Eye 18Foreign Black Border · rare · 11 Apr 1994	Foreign Black Border	rare	11 Apr 1994	—	€0.74Normal
Eye for an Eye 4Arabian Nights · uncommon · 17 Dec 1993	Arabian Nights	uncommon	17 Dec 1993	$43.64Normal	€17.90Normal

For each market, the first figure is the printing’s cheapest non-foil market price and the second its dearest foil one, each with its variant. Prices last updated 18 Oct 2026, refreshed daily at 03:00 UTC. Price information only; Dexicards does not sell cards.