Identity Thief

5 Magic: The Gathering cards are named Identity Thief, across 4 sets released from 2016 to 2022. The newest printing is from New Capenna Commander, released 29 Apr 2022. As of 16 Oct 2026, the most valuable is Identity Thief 64s from Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens (Foil) at $0.43 on TCGplayer and the same printing (Foil) at €0.45 on Cardmarket. The cheapest is Identity Thief 64 from Eldritch Moon (Normal) at $0.18 on TCGplayer and Identity Thief 64 from Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens (Foil) at €0.13 on Cardmarket.

Every Identity Thief printing with its cheapest non-foil and dearest foil TCGplayer (USD) and Cardmarket (EUR) market price and variant

Card	Set	Rarity	Released	TCGplayerUSD	CardmarketEUR
Identity Thief 224New Capenna Commander · rare · 29 Apr 2022	New Capenna Commander	rare	29 Apr 2022	$0.29Normal	€0.18Normal
Identity Thief 64Eldritch Moon · rare · 22 Jul 2016	Eldritch Moon	rare	22 Jul 2016	$0.18Normal$0.39Foil	€0.14Normal€0.39Foil
Identity Thief 64Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens · rare · 22 Jul 2016	Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens	rare	22 Jul 2016	$0.33Foil	€0.13Foil
Identity Thief 64sEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · rare · 22 Jul 2016	Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens	rare	22 Jul 2016	$0.43Foil	€0.21Normal€0.45Foil
Identity Thief 61559Magic Online Promos · rare · 24 Jun 2002	Magic Online Promos	rare	24 Jun 2002	—	—

For each market, the first figure is the printing’s cheapest non-foil market price and the second its dearest foil one, each with its variant. Prices last updated 16 Oct 2026, refreshed daily at 03:00 UTC. Price information only; Dexicards does not sell cards.