Nightmare

32 Magic: The Gathering cards are named Nightmare, across 27 sets released from 1993 to 2023. The newest printing is from Wilds of Eldraine Tokens, released 8 Sep 2023. As of 15 Oct 2026, the most valuable is Nightmare 118 from Limited Edition Alpha (Normal) at $1,399.99 on TCGplayer and Nightmare 120 from Summer Magic / Edgar (Normal) at €1,464.00 on Cardmarket. The cheapest is Nightmare 276 from Magic 2015 (Normal) at $0.15 on TCGplayer and the same printing (Foil) at €0.02 on Cardmarket.

Every Nightmare printing with its highest TCGplayer (USD) and Cardmarket (EUR) market price and variant

Card	Set	Rarity	Released	TCGplayerUSD	CardmarketEUR
Nightmare 6Wilds of Eldraine Tokens · 8 Sep 2023	Wilds of Eldraine Tokens	—	8 Sep 2023	$0.30Normal	—
Nightmare 11530th Anniversary Edition · rare · 28 Nov 2022	30th Anniversary Edition	rare	28 Nov 2022	—	€27.10Normal
Nightmare 41230th Anniversary Edition · rare · 28 Nov 2022	30th Anniversary Edition	rare	28 Nov 2022	$80.00Normal	€95.00Normal
Nightmare W17-17The List Tokens · rare · 26 Sep 2020	The List Tokens	rare	26 Sep 2020	$0.37Normal	€0.20Normal
Nightmare 54Arena Beginner Set · rare · 13 Aug 2020	Arena Beginner Set	rare	13 Aug 2020	—	—
Nightmare 12Theros Beyond Death Tokens · 24 Jan 2020	Theros Beyond Death Tokens	—	24 Jan 2020	$0.58Normal	€1.34Foil
Nightmare 17Welcome Deck 2017 · rare · 15 Apr 2017	Welcome Deck 2017	rare	15 Apr 2017	$0.22Normal	€0.05Normal
Nightmare 8Welcome Deck 2016 · rare · 8 Apr 2016	Welcome Deck 2016	rare	8 Apr 2016	$0.16Normal	€0.19Foil
Nightmare 282Magic Origins · rare · 17 Jul 2015	Magic Origins	rare	17 Jul 2015	$0.16Normal	€0.11Normal
Nightmare 276Magic 2015 · rare · 18 Jul 2014	Magic 2015	rare	18 Jul 2014	$0.15Normal	€0.09Normal
Nightmare 108Magic 2014 · rare · 19 Jul 2013	Magic 2014	rare	19 Jul 2013	$0.75Foil	€0.77Foil
Nightmare 107Magic 2010 · rare · 17 Jul 2009	Magic 2010	rare	17 Jul 2009	$0.70Foil	€0.45Foil
Nightmare 164Tenth Edition · rare · 13 Jul 2007	Tenth Edition	rare	13 Jul 2007	$2.71Foil	€3.59Foil
Nightmare 164★Tenth Edition · rare · 13 Jul 2007	Tenth Edition	rare	13 Jul 2007	$2.71Foil	€3.34Foil
Nightmare 150Ninth Edition · rare · 29 Jul 2005	Ninth Edition	rare	29 Jul 2005	$6.19Foil	€11.70Foil
Nightmare 150★Ninth Edition · rare · 29 Jul 2005	Ninth Edition	rare	29 Jul 2005	$6.19Foil	—
Nightmare 150Eighth Edition · rare · 28 Jul 2003	Eighth Edition	rare	28 Jul 2003	$4.73Foil	€4.65Foil
Nightmare 150★Eighth Edition · rare · 28 Jul 2003	Eighth Edition	rare	28 Jul 2003	$4.73Foil	—
Nightmare 150Seventh Edition · rare · 11 Apr 2001	Seventh Edition	rare	11 Apr 2001	$99.99Foil	€110.39Foil
Nightmare 150★Seventh Edition · rare · 11 Apr 2001	Seventh Edition	rare	11 Apr 2001	$99.99Foil	—
Nightmare 146Classic Sixth Edition · rare · 21 Apr 1999	Classic Sixth Edition	rare	21 Apr 1999	$0.91Normal	€0.68Normal
Nightmare 184Fifth Edition · rare · 24 Mar 1997	Fifth Edition	rare	24 Mar 1997	$1.28Normal	€1.02Normal
Nightmare 150Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border · rare · 1 Apr 1995	Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border	rare	1 Apr 1995	—	€7.19Normal
Nightmare 150Fourth Edition · rare · 1 Apr 1995	Fourth Edition	rare	1 Apr 1995	$2.06Normal	€1.00Normal
Nightmare 120Summer Magic / Edgar · rare · 21 Jun 1994	Summer Magic / Edgar	rare	21 Jun 1994	—	€1,464.00Normal
Nightmare 120Revised Edition · rare · 11 Apr 1994	Revised Edition	rare	11 Apr 1994	$7.58Normal	€4.59Normal
Nightmare 120Foreign Black Border · rare · 11 Apr 1994	Foreign Black Border	rare	11 Apr 1994	—	€14.19Normal
Nightmare 119Collectors' Edition · rare · 10 Dec 1993	Collectors' Edition	rare	10 Dec 1993	$17.75Normal	€12.24Normal
Nightmare 119Intl. Collectors' Edition · rare · 10 Dec 1993	Intl. Collectors' Edition	rare	10 Dec 1993	$22.77Normal	€11.35Normal
Nightmare 119Unlimited Edition · rare · 1 Dec 1993	Unlimited Edition	rare	1 Dec 1993	$88.00Normal	€27.42Normal
Nightmare 119Limited Edition Beta · rare · 4 Oct 1993	Limited Edition Beta	rare	4 Oct 1993	—	€532.75Normal
Nightmare 118Limited Edition Alpha · rare · 5 Aug 1993	Limited Edition Alpha	rare	5 Aug 1993	$1,399.99Normal	€1,225.14Normal

Each figure is the printing’s highest market price in that market, with its variant. Prices last updated 15 Oct 2026, refreshed daily at 03:00 UTC. Price information only; Dexicards does not sell cards.