| Pick Your PoisonSecrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive · 120 | Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 120 | Uncommon | $0.39 |
| Pick Your PoisonSecrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive · 185 | Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 185 | Uncommon | $5.41 |
| Pick Your PoisonThe List Tokens · MKM-170 | The List Tokens | MKM-170 | Common | $0.15 |
| Picnic Ruiner // Stolen GoodiesWilds of Eldraine · 232 | Wilds of Eldraine | 232 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Pictures of Spider-ManMarvel's Spider-Man · 109 | Marvel's Spider-Man | 109 | Uncommon | €0.10 |
| Pictures of Spider-ManThrough the Omenpaths · 99 | Through the Omenpaths | 99 | Uncommon | — |
| Piece It TogetherAlchemy: The Brothers' War · 5 | Alchemy: The Brothers' War | 5 | Uncommon | — |
| Pieces of the PuzzleShadows over Innistrad · 78 | Shadows over Innistrad | 78 | Common | $0.17 |
| Pieces of the PuzzleShadows over Innistrad Remastered · 85 | Shadows over Innistrad Remastered | 85 | Uncommon | — |
| Pie-Eating ContestUnfinity · 151 | Unfinity | 151 | Uncommon | €0.06 |
| Pie-Eating ContestUnfinity · 437 | Unfinity | 437 | Uncommon | $0.42 |
| Pierce StriderBattlebond · 244 | Battlebond | 244 | Common | $0.06 |
| Pierce StriderJumpstart 2022 · 790 | Jumpstart 2022 | 790 | Uncommon | €0.14 |
| Pierce StriderMirrodin Besieged · 123 | Mirrodin Besieged | 123 | Uncommon | $0.07 |
| Pierce StriderMagic Online Promos · 39017 | Magic Online Promos | 39017 | Uncommon | — |
| Pierce the SkyDominaria · 176 | Dominaria | 176 | Common | €0.03 |
| Pierce the SkyThe List Tokens · DOM-176 | The List Tokens | DOM-176 | Common | €0.05 |
| Piercing ExhaleTarkir: Dragonstorm · 151 | Tarkir: Dragonstorm | 151 | Common | €0.11 |
| Piercing LightInnistrad: Double Feature · 297 | Innistrad: Double Feature | 297 | Common | €0.06 |
| Piercing LightInnistrad: Crimson Vow · 30 | Innistrad: Crimson Vow | 30 | Common | €0.04 |
| Piercing RaysModern Horizons 2 · 24 | Modern Horizons 2 | 24 | Common | €0.06 |
| Piercing Rays // Piercing RaysModern Horizons 2 Art Series · 4 | Modern Horizons 2 Art Series | 4 | — | — |
| Piercing Rays // Piercing RaysModern Horizons 2 Art Series · 4s | Modern Horizons 2 Art Series | 4s | — | — |
| Pietra, Crafter of ClownsUnfinity · 176 | Unfinity | 176 | Uncommon | €0.05 |
| Pietra, Crafter of ClownsUnfinity · 268 | Unfinity | 268 | Uncommon | €0.02 |
| Pietra, Crafter of ClownsUnfinity · 462 | Unfinity | 462 | Uncommon | €0.39 |
| Pietra, Crafter of ClownsUnfinity · 519 | Unfinity | 519 | Uncommon | $0.28 |
| PietyFourth Edition Foreign Black Border · 41 | Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border | 41 | Common | €0.18 |
| PietyFourth Edition · 41 | Fourth Edition | 41 | Common | $0.09 |
| PietyArabian Nights · 8 | Arabian Nights | 8 | Common | €2.29 |
| PietyArabian Nights · 8† | Arabian Nights | 8† | Common | €7.60 |
| PietyRenaissance · 17 | Renaissance | 17 | Common | €0.10 |
| Piety CharmOnslaught · 49 | Onslaught | 49 | Common | €0.09 |
| Piggy BankDuskmourn: House of Horror · 148 | Duskmourn: House of Horror | 148 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Pigment StormFoundations Jumpstart · 585 | Foundations Jumpstart | 585 | Common | $0.11 |
| Pigment StormStrixhaven: School of Mages · 111 | Strixhaven: School of Mages | 111 | Common | €0.06 |
| Pigment Wrangler // Striking PaletteSecrets of Strixhaven · 126 | Secrets of Strixhaven | 126 | Uncommon | €0.10 |
| PikemenFourth Edition Foreign Black Border · 42 | Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border | 42 | Common | €0.17 |
| PikemenFourth Edition · 42 | Fourth Edition | 42 | Common | €0.07 |
| PikemenFifth Edition · 52 | Fifth Edition | 52 | Common | €0.08 |
| PikemenThe Dark · 15 | The Dark | 15 | Common | $0.33 |
| PikemenRenaissance · 18 | Renaissance | 18 | Common | €0.09 |
| Pileated ProvisionerBloomburrow · 25 | Bloomburrow | 25 | Common | $0.07 |
| Pile OnMurders at Karlov Manor Commander · 134 | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander | 134 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Pile OnMarch of the Machine · 122 | March of the Machine | 122 | Rare | €0.16 |
| Pile OnMarch of the Machine · 361 | March of the Machine | 361 | Rare | $0.38 |
| Pile OnMarch of the Machine Promos · 122p | March of the Machine Promos | 122p | Rare | €0.22 |
| Pile OnMarch of the Machine Promos · 122s | March of the Machine Promos | 122s | Rare | $0.69 |
| PilferDominaria United · 102 | Dominaria United | 102 | Uncommon | €0.15 |
| PilferFoundations · 181 | Foundations | 181 | Common | €0.13 |