| PlaxmantaThe List Tokens · DIS-29 | The List Tokens | DIS-29 | Uncommon | €0.07 |
| Playable Delusionary HydraUnfinity Sticker Sheets · 30 | Unfinity Sticker Sheets | 30 | Common | $2.80 |
| Playful ShoveBloomburrow · 145 | Bloomburrow | 145 | Uncommon | $0.22 |
| Play of the GameBattlebond · 29 | Battlebond | 29 | Rare | €0.43 |
| Playtest WishUnknown Event · RC02 | Unknown Event | RC02 | Rare | $26.74 |
| Play with FireInnistrad: Double Feature · 154 | Innistrad: Double Feature | 154 | Uncommon | $0.51 |
| Play with FireFoundations Jumpstart · 586 | Foundations Jumpstart | 586 | Uncommon | $0.34 |
| Play with FireInnistrad: Midnight Hunt · 154 | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt | 154 | Uncommon | $0.25 |
| Play with FireInnistrad: Midnight Hunt · 390 | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt | 390 | Uncommon | €0.39 |
| Plaza of HarmonyRavnica Allegiance Promos · 254p | Ravnica Allegiance Promos | 254p | Rare | $0.43 |
| Plaza of HarmonyRavnica Allegiance · 254 | Ravnica Allegiance | 254 | Rare | $0.37 |
| Plaza of HarmonyThe List Tokens · RNA-254 | The List Tokens | RNA-254 | Rare | $0.51 |
| Plaza of HeroesDominaria United · 252 | Dominaria United | 252 | Rare | $5.27 |
| Plaza of HeroesDominaria United · 421 | Dominaria United | 421 | Rare | €7.74 |
| Plaza of HeroesEdge of Eternities: Stellar Sights · 33 | Edge of Eternities: Stellar Sights | 33 | Mythic Rare | €8.50 |
| Plaza of HeroesEdge of Eternities: Stellar Sights · 78 | Edge of Eternities: Stellar Sights | 78 | Mythic Rare | €41.69 |
| Plaza of HeroesEdge of Eternities: Stellar Sights · 123 | Edge of Eternities: Stellar Sights | 123 | Mythic Rare | €51.25 |
| Plaza of HeroesEdge of Eternities: Stellar Sights · 168 | Edge of Eternities: Stellar Sights | 168 | Mythic Rare | €162.85 |
| Plaza of HeroesMarvel Super Heroes Commander · 255 | Marvel Super Heroes Commander | 255 | Rare | $3.76 |
| Plaza of HeroesDominaria United Promos · 252p | Dominaria United Promos | 252p | Rare | €6.28 |
| Plaza of HeroesDominaria United Promos · 252s | Dominaria United Promos | 252s | Rare | €8.80 |
| Plaza of HeroesMagic Online Promos · 103488 | Magic Online Promos | 103488 | Rare | — |
| Plaza of HeroesMarvel Super Heroes Commander · 483 | Marvel Super Heroes Commander | 483 | Rare | €5.77 |
| Plea for GuidanceBorn of the Gods · 24 | Born of the Gods | 24 | Rare | €0.51 |
| Plea for PowerConspiracy · 24 | Conspiracy | 24 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Plea for PowerGame Night: Free-for-All · 33 | Game Night: Free-for-All | 33 | Rare | €0.37 |
| Plea for PowerTales of Middle-earth Commander · 195 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 195 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Plea for PowerThe List Tokens · CNS-24 | The List Tokens | CNS-24 | Rare | €0.22 |
| Plea for PowerVintage Masters · 87 | Vintage Masters | 87 | Rare | — |
| Pledge of LoyaltyInvasion · 24 | Invasion | 24 | Uncommon | €0.11 |
| Pledge of LoyaltyThe List Tokens · INV-24 | The List Tokens | INV-24 | Uncommon | €0.09 |
| Pledge of UnityWar of the Spark · 210 | War of the Spark | 210 | Uncommon | €0.27 |
| PlotOutlaws of Thunder Junction Tokens · 20 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Tokens | 20 | — | — |
| Plot ArmorUnfinity · 152 | Unfinity | 152 | Common | €0.08 |
| Plot ArmorUnfinity · 438 | Unfinity | 438 | Common | €0.32 |
| Plots That Span CenturiesDCI Promos · 54 | DCI Promos | 54 | Rare | €5.29 |
| Plots That Span CenturiesDuskmourn: House of Horror Commander · 351 | Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander | 351 | Common | $0.45 |
| Plover KnightsDuel Decks: Knights vs. Dragons · 20 | Duel Decks: Knights vs. Dragons | 20 | Common | €0.06 |
| Plover KnightsLorwyn · 35 | Lorwyn | 35 | Common | €0.08 |
| Plow ThroughAetherdrift · 174 | Aetherdrift | 174 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Plow Through ReitoSaviors of Kamigawa · 22 | Saviors of Kamigawa | 22 | Common | €0.08 |
| Plow UnderEighth Edition · 272 | Eighth Edition | 272 | Rare | €0.70 |
| Plow UnderEighth Edition · 272★ | Eighth Edition | 272★ | Rare | $1.01 |
| Plow UnderUrza's Destiny · 117 | Urza's Destiny | 117 | Rare | €1.62 |
| Plow UnderWorld Championship Decks 2000 Tokens · jk117 | World Championship Decks 2000 Tokens | jk117 | Rare | €0.39 |
| Plow UnderWorld Championship Decks 2004 Tokens · jn272 | World Championship Decks 2004 Tokens | jn272 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Plow UnderWorld Championship Decks 2004 Tokens · jn272sb | World Championship Decks 2004 Tokens | jn272sb | Rare | $0.49 |
| Plumb the ForbiddenBloomburrow Commander · 188 | Bloomburrow Commander | 188 | Uncommon | €0.73 |
| Plumb the ForbiddenSecrets of Strixhaven Commander · 224 | Secrets of Strixhaven Commander | 224 | Uncommon | $0.42 |
| Plumb the ForbiddenStrixhaven: School of Mages · 81 | Strixhaven: School of Mages | 81 | Uncommon | $0.44 |