| Yarok, the DesecratedSecret Lair Countdown · 52 | Secret Lair Countdown | 52 | Mythic Rare | €38.15 |
| Yavimaya, Cradle of GrowthTales of Middle-earth Commander · 377 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 377 | Mythic Rare | €42.52 |
| Yavimaya, Cradle of GrowthTales of Middle-earth Commander · 407 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 407 | Mythic Rare | $200.18 |
| Yavimaya, Cradle of GrowthTales of Middle-earth Commander · 407z | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 407z | Mythic Rare | €2,052.57 |
| Yawgmoth's BargainVintage Masters · 147 | Vintage Masters | 147 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Yawgmoth's WillVintage Masters · 148 | Vintage Masters | 148 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Yawgmoth, Thran PhysicianDominaria Remastered · 110 | Dominaria Remastered | 110 | Mythic Rare | $27.73 |
| Yawgmoth, Thran PhysicianDominaria Remastered · 315 | Dominaria Remastered | 315 | Mythic Rare | $23.69 |
| Yawgmoth, Thran PhysicianDominaria Remastered · 431 | Dominaria Remastered | 431 | Mythic Rare | $27.41 |
| Yawgmoth, Thran PhysicianFinal Fantasy: Through the Ages · 11 | Final Fantasy: Through the Ages | 11 | Mythic Rare | €27.55 |
| Yawgmoth, Thran PhysicianModern Horizons · 116 | Modern Horizons | 116 | Mythic Rare | $26.16 |
| Yawgmoth, Thran PhysicianJumpstart: Historic Horizons · 405 | Jumpstart: Historic Horizons | 405 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Yennett, Cryptic SovereignCommander 2018 · 51 | Commander 2018 | 51 | Mythic Rare | €0.58 |
| Yennett, Cryptic SovereignTreasure Chest · 70747 | Treasure Chest | 70747 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Yggdrasil, Rebirth EngineAssassin's Creed · 78 | Assassin's Creed | 78 | Mythic Rare | $1.35 |
| Yggdrasil, Rebirth EngineAssassin's Creed · 126 | Assassin's Creed | 126 | Mythic Rare | $4.63 |
| Yggdrasil, Rebirth EngineAssassin's Creed · 264 | Assassin's Creed | 264 | Mythic Rare | $3.62 |
| Ygra, Eater of AllBloomburrow · 241 | Bloomburrow | 241 | Mythic Rare | €7.82 |
| Ygra, Eater of AllBloomburrow · 294 | Bloomburrow | 294 | Mythic Rare | €13.67 |
| Ygra, Eater of AllBloomburrow Promos · 241p | Bloomburrow Promos | 241p | Mythic Rare | €8.03 |
| Ygra, Eater of AllBloomburrow Promos · 241s | Bloomburrow Promos | 241s | Mythic Rare | €11.55 |
| Yidris, Maelstrom WielderCommander 2016 · 50 | Commander 2016 | 50 | Mythic Rare | €5.26 |
| Yidris, Maelstrom WielderCommander 2016 Oversized · 50 | Commander 2016 Oversized | 50 | Mythic Rare | €0.23 |
| Yidris, Maelstrom WielderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 455 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 455 | Mythic Rare | €4.65 |
| Yidris, Maelstrom WielderTreasure Chest · 64 | Treasure Chest | 64 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Yidris, Maelstrom WielderThe List Tokens · C16-50 | The List Tokens | C16-50 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Yosei, the Morning StarModern Masters · 35 | Modern Masters | 35 | Mythic Rare | €1.18 |
| Yoshimaru, Ever FaithfulNeon Dynasty Commander · 32 | Neon Dynasty Commander | 32 | Mythic Rare | $8.46 |
| Yoshimaru, Ever FaithfulNeon Dynasty Commander · 46 | Neon Dynasty Commander | 46 | Mythic Rare | €7.90 |
| Yoshimaru, Ever FaithfulMagicFest 2025 · 5 | MagicFest 2025 | 5 | Mythic Rare | $35.63 |
| Yoshimaru, Ever FaithfulSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 794 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 794 | Mythic Rare | €46.40 |
| Yoshimaru, Ever FaithfulSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2463 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2463 | Mythic Rare | $7.99 |
| Yoshimaru, Ever FaithfulMagic Online Promos · 97905 | Magic Online Promos | 97905 | Mythic Rare | — |
| You, Iterative PlaytesterUnknown Event · MW02a | Unknown Event | MW02a | Mythic Rare | — |
| You, Magic PlaytesterUnknown Event · MW02 | Unknown Event | MW02 | Mythic Rare | $25.50 |
| Y'shtola, Night's BlessedFinal Fantasy Commander · 7 | Final Fantasy Commander | 7 | Mythic Rare | €1.57 |
| Y'shtola, Night's BlessedFinal Fantasy Commander · 191 | Final Fantasy Commander | 191 | Mythic Rare | €11.18 |
| Y'shtola, Night's BlessedFinal Fantasy Commander · 207 | Final Fantasy Commander | 207 | Mythic Rare | €160.99 |
| Y'shtola, Night's BlessedFinal Fantasy Commander · 215 | Final Fantasy Commander | 215 | Mythic Rare | €1,040.44 |
| Y'shtola, Night's BlessedFinal Fantasy Commander · 226 | Final Fantasy Commander | 226 | Mythic Rare | €10.59 |
| Y'shtola RhulFinal Fantasy · 86 | Final Fantasy | 86 | Mythic Rare | €4.41 |
| Y'shtola RhulFinal Fantasy · 443 | Final Fantasy | 443 | Mythic Rare | €10.99 |
| Y'shtola RhulFinal Fantasy · 577 | Final Fantasy | 577 | Mythic Rare | €19.25 |
| Y'shtola RhulFinal Fantasy Promos · 86s | Final Fantasy Promos | 86s | Mythic Rare | €13.93 |
| Yuma, Proud ProtectorOutlaws of Thunder Junction Commander · 4 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander | 4 | Mythic Rare | €0.35 |
| Yuna, Grand SummonerFinal Fantasy Commander · 8 | Final Fantasy Commander | 8 | Mythic Rare | $0.45 |
| Yuna, Grand SummonerFinal Fantasy Commander · 192 | Final Fantasy Commander | 192 | Mythic Rare | $4.16 |
| Yuna, Grand SummonerFinal Fantasy Commander · 208 | Final Fantasy Commander | 208 | Mythic Rare | €37.89 |
| Yuna, Grand SummonerFinal Fantasy Commander · 216 | Final Fantasy Commander | 216 | Mythic Rare | €275.01 |
| Yuna, Grand SummonerFinal Fantasy Commander · 227 | Final Fantasy Commander | 227 | Mythic Rare | $4.28 |