| Icy ManipulatorNinth Edition · 299★ | Ninth Edition | 299★ | Uncommon | $0.26 |
| Icy ManipulatorCollectors' Edition · 249 | Collectors' Edition | 249 | Uncommon | €39.13 |
| Icy ManipulatorIntl. Collectors' Edition · 249 | Intl. Collectors' Edition | 249 | Uncommon | $0.50 |
| Icy ManipulatorDuel Decks: Ajani vs. Nicol Bolas · 64 | Duel Decks: Ajani vs. Nicol Bolas | 64 | Uncommon | €0.13 |
| Icy ManipulatorDeckmasters · 36 | Deckmasters | 36 | Uncommon | €0.36 |
| Icy ManipulatorDeckmasters · 36★ | Deckmasters | 36★ | Uncommon | $0.42 |
| Icy ManipulatorDominaria Remastered · 225 | Dominaria Remastered | 225 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Icy ManipulatorDominaria · 219 | Dominaria | 219 | Uncommon | €0.11 |
| Icy ManipulatorDominaria Remastered · 380 | Dominaria Remastered | 380 | Uncommon | €0.15 |
| Icy ManipulatorIce Age · 322 | Ice Age | 322 | Uncommon | €1.09 |
| Icy ManipulatorLimited Edition Alpha · 248 | Limited Edition Alpha | 248 | Uncommon | $745.47 |
| Icy ManipulatorLimited Edition Beta · 249 | Limited Edition Beta | 249 | Uncommon | €191.67 |
| Icy ManipulatorMirrodin · 186 | Mirrodin | 186 | Uncommon | €0.13 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · bl322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | bl322 | Uncommon | €0.38 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · et322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | et322 | Uncommon | €0.27 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · mj322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | mj322 | Uncommon | $0.45 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · ml322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | ml322 | Uncommon | €0.46 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · pp322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | pp322 | Uncommon | €0.31 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · shr322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | shr322 | Uncommon | €0.28 |
| Icy ManipulatorThe List Tokens · DOM-219 | The List Tokens | DOM-219 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Icy ManipulatorMasters Edition IV · 207 | Masters Edition IV | 207 | Uncommon | — |
| Icy ManipulatorMagic Online Promos · 35042 | Magic Online Promos | 35042 | Uncommon | — |
| Identify the CulpritUnknown Event · UW02c | Unknown Event | UW02c | Uncommon | — |
| Idle ThoughtsEventide · 23 | Eventide | 23 | Uncommon | $0.17 |
| Idol of False GodsModern Horizons 3 · 210 | Modern Horizons 3 | 210 | Uncommon | €0.20 |
| Idol of OblivionModern Horizons 3 Commander · 297 | Modern Horizons 3 Commander | 297 | Uncommon | €2.85 |
| Idol of OblivionThe List Tokens · M3C-297 | The List Tokens | M3C-297 | Uncommon | $3.60 |
| Ifnir DeadlandsLorwyn Eclipsed Commander · 153 | Lorwyn Eclipsed Commander | 153 | Uncommon | €0.20 |
| Ifnir DeadlandsHour of Devastation · 179 | Hour of Devastation | 179 | Uncommon | $0.25 |
| Ifnir DeadlandsAmonkhet Remastered · 302 | Amonkhet Remastered | 302 | Uncommon | — |
| Igneous GolemMirage · 305 | Mirage | 305 | Uncommon | $0.14 |
| Igneous InspirationStrixhaven: School of Mages · 107 | Strixhaven: School of Mages | 107 | Uncommon | $0.09 |
| Ignis ScientiaFinal Fantasy · 227 | Final Fantasy | 227 | Uncommon | €0.10 |
| Ignis ScientiaFinal Fantasy · 492 | Final Fantasy | 492 | Uncommon | €0.90 |
| Ignite DisorderConflux · 66 | Conflux | 66 | Uncommon | €0.04 |
| Ignite DisorderMagic 2010 · 141 | Magic 2010 | 141 | Uncommon | $0.02 |
| Ignite MemoriesTime Spiral · 164 | Time Spiral | 164 | Uncommon | €0.32 |
| Ignoble SoldierMercadian Masques · 22 | Mercadian Masques | 22 | Uncommon | €0.13 |
| Ignorant BlissDissension · 64 | Dissension | 64 | Uncommon | €0.13 |
| Ihsan's ShadeMasters 25 · 94 | Masters 25 | 94 | Uncommon | €0.20 |
| Ihsan's ShadeAnthologies · 25 | Anthologies | 25 | Uncommon | $0.24 |
| Ihsan's ShadeHomelands · 53 | Homelands | 53 | Uncommon | $0.35 |
| Ihsan's ShadePro Tour Collector Set Tokens · gb53 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | gb53 | Uncommon | $0.79 |
| Ihsan's ShadePro Tour Collector Set Tokens · gb53sb | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | gb53sb | Uncommon | €0.91 |
| Ihsan's ShadeThe List Tokens · A25-94 | The List Tokens | A25-94 | Uncommon | $0.20 |
| Illicit ShipmentStreets of New Capenna · 83 | Streets of New Capenna | 83 | Uncommon | €0.11 |
| Illness in the RanksGatecrash · 69 | Gatecrash | 69 | Uncommon | $0.19 |
| Illness in the RanksPioneer Masters · 292 | Pioneer Masters | 292 | Uncommon | — |
| IlluminateApocalypse · 63 | Apocalypse | 63 | Uncommon | $0.11 |
| Illuminated FolioShadowmoor · 254 | Shadowmoor | 254 | Uncommon | €0.12 |