| PillageWorld Championship Decks 1999 Tokens · mlp198 | World Championship Decks 1999 Tokens | mlp198 | Uncommon | $0.25 |
| PillageMasters Edition II · 146 | Masters Edition II | 146 | Uncommon | — |
| PillageMagic Online Promos · 35994 | Magic Online Promos | 35994 | Uncommon | — |
| Pillaging HordeVintage Masters · 180 | Vintage Masters | 180 | Uncommon | — |
| Pillar of OriginsCommander Masters · 970 | Commander Masters | 970 | Uncommon | €0.49 |
| Pillar of OriginsIxalan · 241 | Ixalan | 241 | Uncommon | €0.26 |
| Pillar of WarBorn of the Gods · 160 | Born of the Gods | 160 | Uncommon | €0.04 |
| Pillory of the SleeplessMasters 25 · 213 | Masters 25 | 213 | Uncommon | €0.22 |
| Pillory of the SleeplessRNA Guild Kit · 44 | RNA Guild Kit | 44 | Uncommon | $0.19 |
| Pillory of the SleeplessModern Masters 2015 · 183 | Modern Masters 2015 | 183 | Uncommon | €0.14 |
| Pillory of the SleeplessThe List Tokens · A25-213 | The List Tokens | A25-213 | Uncommon | €0.11 |
| Pin CollectionUnfinity · 23 | Unfinity | 23 | Uncommon | €0.06 |
| Pin CollectionUnfinity · 309 | Unfinity | 309 | Uncommon | €0.64 |
| Pine BarrensTempest Remastered · 240 | Tempest Remastered | 240 | Uncommon | — |
| Pine BarrensVintage Masters · 307 | Vintage Masters | 307 | Uncommon | — |
| Pinecrest RidgeChampions of Kamigawa · 281 | Champions of Kamigawa | 281 | Uncommon | €0.11 |
| Pine WalkerKhans of Tarkir · 143 | Khans of Tarkir | 143 | Uncommon | €0.10 |
| Pinnacle Monk // Mystic PeakModern Horizons 3 · 246 | Modern Horizons 3 | 246 | Uncommon | €1.66 |
| Pinnacle of RageBorn of the Gods · 105 | Born of the Gods | 105 | Uncommon | €0.07 |
| Pious Evangel // Wayward DiscipleShadows over Innistrad · 34 | Shadows over Innistrad | 34 | Uncommon | €0.11 |
| Piper's MelodyOdyssey · 261 | Odyssey | 261 | Uncommon | €0.17 |
| Pipsqueak, Rebel StrongarmAvatar: The Last Airbender Eternal · 82 | Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal | 82 | Uncommon | $0.18 |
| Pirate's LandingAlchemy: Ixalan · 16 | Alchemy: Ixalan | 16 | Uncommon | — |
| Pirate's PillageRivals of Ixalan · 109 | Rivals of Ixalan | 109 | Uncommon | €0.46 |
| Piston SledgeMirrodin Besieged · 124 | Mirrodin Besieged | 124 | Uncommon | $0.13 |
| Pit AutomatonAetherdrift · 238 | Aetherdrift | 238 | Uncommon | €0.09 |
| Pitchstone WallThe List Tokens · TOR-110 | The List Tokens | TOR-110 | Uncommon | €0.12 |
| Pitchstone WallTorment · 110 | Torment | 110 | Uncommon | €0.09 |
| Pitfall TrapZendikar · 32 | Zendikar | 32 | Uncommon | €0.07 |
| Pitiless FistsLorwyn Eclipsed · 187 | Lorwyn Eclipsed | 187 | Uncommon | €0.06 |
| Pitiless PlundererFinal Fantasy Commander · 281 | Final Fantasy Commander | 281 | Uncommon | $3.16 |
| Pitiless PlundererFoundations Jumpstart · 476 | Foundations Jumpstart | 476 | Uncommon | €3.60 |
| Pitiless PlundererThe Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander · 208 | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander | 208 | Uncommon | €3.80 |
| Pitiless PlundererMystery Booster 2 Tokens · 46 | Mystery Booster 2 Tokens | 46 | Uncommon | €2.86 |
| Pitiless PlundererFallout · 187 | Fallout | 187 | Uncommon | $3.65 |
| Pitiless PlundererFallout · 715 | Fallout | 715 | Uncommon | €18.41 |
| Pitiless PlundererThe List Tokens · RIX-81 | The List Tokens | RIX-81 | Uncommon | €4.65 |
| Pitiless PlundererRivals of Ixalan · 81 | Rivals of Ixalan | 81 | Uncommon | €3.40 |
| Pitiless PlundererSpecial Guests · 5 | Special Guests | 5 | Uncommon | €15.71 |
| Pitiless PontiffRavnica Allegiance · 194 | Ravnica Allegiance | 194 | Uncommon | €0.09 |
| Pit of OfferingsThe Lost Caverns of Ixalan · 278 | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan | 278 | Uncommon | €0.24 |
| Pit RaptorProphecy · 72 | Prophecy | 72 | Uncommon | €0.14 |
| Pit TrapSeventh Edition · 313 | Seventh Edition | 313 | Uncommon | €0.21 |
| Pit TrapSeventh Edition · 313★ | Seventh Edition | 313★ | Uncommon | $0.23 |
| Pit TrapIce Age · 333 | Ice Age | 333 | Uncommon | €0.22 |
| Pit TrapUrza's Saga · 307 | Urza's Saga | 307 | Uncommon | €0.15 |
| Pizza Face, GastromancerTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles · 163 | Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles | 163 | Uncommon | €0.10 |
| PlaguecrafterForgotten Realms Commander · 107 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 107 | Uncommon | €0.35 |
| PlaguecrafterBloomburrow Commander · 187 | Bloomburrow Commander | 187 | Uncommon | $0.36 |
| PlaguecrafterCommander 2019 · 126 | Commander 2019 | 126 | Uncommon | €0.34 |