| Icebreaker KrakenKaldheim · 345 | Kaldheim | 345 | Rare | $0.56 |
| Icebreaker KrakenKaldheim Promos · 63p | Kaldheim Promos | 63p | Rare | €0.44 |
| Icebreaker KrakenKaldheim Promos · 63s | Kaldheim Promos | 63s | Rare | €0.41 |
| Icebreaker KrakenMagic Online Promos · 88248 | Magic Online Promos | 88248 | Rare | — |
| Ice CauldronIce Age · 321 | Ice Age | 321 | Rare | €1.15 |
| Ice CauldronMasters Edition IV · 206 | Masters Edition IV | 206 | Rare | — |
| Ice CaveApocalypse · 24 | Apocalypse | 24 | Rare | €0.63 |
| Ice CaveThe List Tokens · APC-24 | The List Tokens | APC-24 | Rare | €1.35 |
| Icefall RegentArchenemy: Nicol Bolas · 24 | Archenemy: Nicol Bolas | 24 | Rare | €0.22 |
| Icefall RegentDragons of Tarkir · 58 | Dragons of Tarkir | 58 | Rare | €0.27 |
| Icefall RegentDragons of Tarkir Promos · 58s | Dragons of Tarkir Promos | 58s | Rare | €0.84 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlModern Horizons 1 Timeshifts · 27 | Modern Horizons 1 Timeshifts | 27 | Rare | €0.60 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlMystery Booster 2 Tokens · 83 | Mystery Booster 2 Tokens | 83 | Rare | $0.37 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlModern Horizons · 203 | Modern Horizons | 203 | Rare | $0.68 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 171 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 171 | Rare | $2.00 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1225 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1225 | Rare | €5.68 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlThe List Tokens · MH1-203 | The List Tokens | MH1-203 | Rare | $1.77 |
| Ice-Fang CoatlMagic Online Promos · 91333 | Magic Online Promos | 91333 | Rare | — |
| Ice OutWizards Play Network 2023 · 7 | Wizards Play Network 2023 | 7 | Rare | €0.21 |
| Ice StormSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1745 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1745 | Rare | $1.64 |
| Icetill ExplorerEdge of Eternities · 192 | Edge of Eternities | 192 | Rare | $22.98 |
| Icetill ExplorerEdge of Eternities · 343 | Edge of Eternities | 343 | Rare | $25.50 |
| Icetill ExplorerEdge of Eternities Promos · 192p | Edge of Eternities Promos | 192p | Rare | $20.91 |
| Icetill ExplorerEdge of Eternities Promos · 192s | Edge of Eternities Promos | 192s | Rare | €25.74 |
| Ichor AberrationAlchemy: Phyrexia · 23 | Alchemy: Phyrexia | 23 | Rare | — |
| Ichor ElixirMarch of the Machine Commander · 46 | March of the Machine Commander | 46 | Rare | $0.17 |
| Ichor ElixirMarch of the Machine Commander · 133 | March of the Machine Commander | 133 | Rare | €0.14 |
| IchoridEternal Masters · 93 | Eternal Masters | 93 | Rare | €0.65 |
| IchoridTorment · 65 | Torment | 65 | Rare | €1.48 |
| IchoridVintage Masters · 123 | Vintage Masters | 123 | Rare | — |
| Icon of AncestryWarhammer 40,000 Commander · 242 | Warhammer 40,000 Commander | 242 | Rare | €0.69 |
| Icon of AncestryWarhammer 40,000 Commander · 242★ | Warhammer 40,000 Commander | 242★ | Rare | $2.73 |
| Icon of AncestryCommander Masters · 955 | Commander Masters | 955 | Rare | €0.50 |
| Icon of AncestryThe Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander · 305 | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander | 305 | Rare | $0.41 |
| Icon of AncestryCore Set 2020 · 229 | Core Set 2020 | 229 | Rare | €0.51 |
| Icon of AncestryCore Set 2020 Promos · 229p | Core Set 2020 Promos | 229p | Rare | $1.63 |
| Icon of AncestryCore Set 2020 Promos · 229s | Core Set 2020 Promos | 229s | Rare | $1.89 |
| Icy BlastKhans of Tarkir · 42 | Khans of Tarkir | 42 | Rare | €0.49 |
| Icy BlastKhans of Tarkir Promos · 42s | Khans of Tarkir Promos | 42s | Rare | €0.46 |
| Icy ManipulatorFriday Night Magic 2005 · 12 | Friday Night Magic 2005 | 12 | Rare | €2.23 |
| Icy ManipulatorOversized League Prizes · 6 | Oversized League Prizes | 6 | Rare | — |
| Icy PrisonIce Age · 74 | Ice Age | 74 | Rare | $0.47 |
| Identity CrisisAlara Reborn · 81 | Alara Reborn | 81 | Rare | $0.30 |
| Identity EchoReality Fracture · 87 | Reality Fracture | 87 | Rare | $0.34 |
| Identity EchoReality Fracture · 371 | Reality Fracture | 371 | Rare | €0.38 |
| Identity EchoReality Fracture Promos · 87p | Reality Fracture Promos | 87p | Rare | €0.70 |
| Identity ThiefEldritch Moon · 64 | Eldritch Moon | 64 | Rare | $0.17 |
| Identity ThiefNew Capenna Commander · 224 | New Capenna Commander | 224 | Rare | €0.15 |
| Identity ThiefEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 64 | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 64 | Rare | €0.15 |
| Identity ThiefEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 64s | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 64s | Rare | €0.21 |