| Identity ThiefMagic Online Promos · 61559 | Magic Online Promos | 61559 | Rare | — |
| IdolizedFallout · 17 | Fallout | 17 | Rare | $1.51 |
| IdolizedFallout · 327 | Fallout | 327 | Rare | €2.31 |
| IdolizedFallout · 545 | Fallout | 545 | Rare | €7.29 |
| IdolizedFallout · 855 | Fallout | 855 | Rare | €11.97 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 · 23 | Core Set 2021 | 23 | Rare | €0.15 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 · 342 | Core Set 2021 | 342 | Rare | €0.29 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 Promos · 23p | Core Set 2021 Promos | 23p | Rare | €0.18 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 Promos · 23s | Core Set 2021 Promos | 23s | Rare | $0.56 |
| Idol of EnduranceMagic Online Promos · 81932 | Magic Online Promos | 81932 | Rare | — |
| Idol of OblivionBloomburrow Commander · 277 | Bloomburrow Commander | 277 | Rare | €4.25 |
| Idol of OblivionThe Brothers' War Commander · 144 | The Brothers' War Commander | 144 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander 2019 · 55 | Commander 2019 | 55 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander 2021 · 246 | Commander 2021 | 246 | Rare | €0.50 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander Masters · 392 | Commander Masters | 392 | Rare | €2.65 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander Masters · 607 | Commander Masters | 607 | Rare | €12.18 |
| Idol of OblivionMurders at Karlov Manor Commander · 229 | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander | 229 | Rare | €0.98 |
| Idol of OblivionNew Capenna Commander · 368 | New Capenna Commander | 368 | Rare | €0.74 |
| Idol of OblivionPhyrexia: All Will Be One Commander · 134 | Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander | 134 | Rare | €2.67 |
| Idol of OblivionOutlaws of Thunder Junction Commander · 258 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Commander | 258 | Rare | €2.95 |
| Idol of OblivionStarter Commander Decks · 268 | Starter Commander Decks | 268 | Rare | $2.76 |
| Idol of OblivionTarkir: Dragonstorm Commander · 319 | Tarkir: Dragonstorm Commander | 319 | Rare | €2.52 |
| Idol of OblivionThe List Tokens · BLC-277 | The List Tokens | BLC-277 | Rare | €1.57 |
| Idris, Soul of the TARDISDoctor Who · 135 | Doctor Who | 135 | Rare | €0.12 |
| Idris, Soul of the TARDISDoctor Who · 419 | Doctor Who | 419 | Rare | €0.33 |
| Idris, Soul of the TARDISDoctor Who · 740 | Doctor Who | 740 | Rare | €0.48 |
| Idris, Soul of the TARDISDoctor Who · 1010 | Doctor Who | 1010 | Rare | €0.47 |
| Idyllic TutorMorningtide · 12 | Morningtide | 12 | Rare | €5.80 |
| Idyllic TutorTheros Beyond Death Promos · 24p | Theros Beyond Death Promos | 24p | Rare | €7.26 |
| Idyllic TutorTheros Beyond Death Promos · 24s | Theros Beyond Death Promos | 24s | Rare | €7.29 |
| Idyllic TutorSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1020 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1020 | Rare | €11.22 |
| Idyllic TutorTheros Beyond Death · 24 | Theros Beyond Death | 24 | Rare | €6.09 |
| Idyllic TutorSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1636 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1636 | Rare | €8.21 |
| Idyllic TutorSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1636★ | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1636★ | Rare | $18.22 |
| Idyllic TutorTheros Beyond Death · 301 | Theros Beyond Death | 301 | Rare | €8.22 |
| Idyllic TutorMagic Online Promos · 79971 | Magic Online Promos | 79971 | Rare | — |
| Ifh-Bíff EfreetArabian Nights · 50 | Arabian Nights | 50 | Rare | €145.38 |
| Ifh-Bíff EfreetMasters Edition · 123 | Masters Edition | 123 | Rare | — |
| Ifh-Bíff EfreetMagic Online Promos · 213 | Magic Online Promos | 213 | Rare | — |
| Ignacio of Myra's MarvelsUnfinity · 112 | Unfinity | 112 | Rare | €0.11 |
| Ignacio of Myra's MarvelsUnfinity · 250 | Unfinity | 250 | Rare | $0.14 |
| Ignacio of Myra's MarvelsUnfinity · 398 | Unfinity | 398 | Rare | $0.25 |
| Ignacio of Myra's MarvelsUnfinity · 501 | Unfinity | 501 | Rare | $0.35 |
| Ignite the BeaconWar of the Spark Promos · 18s | War of the Spark Promos | 18s | Rare | €0.51 |
| Ignite the BeaconWar of the Spark · 18 | War of the Spark | 18 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Ignite the FutureForgotten Realms Commander · 129 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 129 | Rare | $0.39 |
| Ignite the FutureCommander 2019 · 27 | Commander 2019 | 27 | Rare | €0.05 |
| Ignite the FutureCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 797 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 797 | Rare | €0.47 |
| Ignite the FutureJumpstart 2022 · 555 | Jumpstart 2022 | 555 | Rare | €0.27 |
| Ignition TeamConspiracy · 34 | Conspiracy | 34 | Rare | $0.34 |