| Illusionary PresenceIce Age · 76 | Ice Age | 76 | Rare | $0.66 |
| Illusionist's BracersGatecrash · 231 | Gatecrash | 231 | Rare | €3.80 |
| Illusionist's BracersRavnica Remastered · 260 | Ravnica Remastered | 260 | Rare | €3.82 |
| Illusionist's BracersRavnica Remastered · 392 | Ravnica Remastered | 392 | Rare | €4.00 |
| Illusionist's BracersRavnica Remastered · 392z | Ravnica Remastered | 392z | Rare | €223.89 |
| Illusionist's BracersThe List Tokens · GTC-231 | The List Tokens | GTC-231 | Rare | €1.95 |
| Illusionist's GambitBloomburrow Commander · 166 | Bloomburrow Commander | 166 | Rare | €0.28 |
| Illusionist's GambitCommander 2013 · 47 | Commander 2013 | 47 | Rare | €0.34 |
| Illusionist's GambitWilds of Eldraine Commander · 97 | Wilds of Eldraine Commander | 97 | Rare | €0.35 |
| Illusions of GrandeurIce Age · 79 | Ice Age | 79 | Rare | €12.93 |
| Illusions of GrandeurMasters Edition · 40 | Masters Edition | 40 | Rare | — |
| Illusory AmbusherLegendary Cube Prize Pack · 28 | Legendary Cube Prize Pack | 28 | Rare | — |
| Illusory GainsDragons of Tarkir · 59 | Dragons of Tarkir | 59 | Rare | $0.18 |
| Illustrious WanderglyphThe Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander · 9 | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander | 9 | Rare | $16.72 |
| Illustrious WanderglyphThe Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander · 21 | The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander | 21 | Rare | $16.48 |
| Imaginary FriendsMystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 · 7 | Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 | 7 | Rare | €0.02 |
| Imaginary FriendsMystery Booster Playtest Cards 2021 · 7 | Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2021 | 7 | Rare | €0.23 |
| Imaginary PetNinth Edition · 82 | Ninth Edition | 82 | Rare | €0.34 |
| Imaginary PetNinth Edition · 82★ | Ninth Edition | 82★ | Rare | $0.48 |
| Imaginary PetUrza's Saga · 81 | Urza's Saga | 81 | Rare | $0.58 |
| Imi StatueChampions of Kamigawa · 255 | Champions of Kamigawa | 255 | Rare | $0.39 |
| Immaculate MagistrateCommander 2014 · 201 | Commander 2014 | 201 | Rare | €1.19 |
| Immaculate MagistrateCommander Anthology · 117 | Commander Anthology | 117 | Rare | €0.81 |
| Immaculate MagistrateCommander Legends · 234 | Commander Legends | 234 | Rare | €3.38 |
| Immaculate MagistrateCommander Legends · 679 | Commander Legends | 679 | Rare | €5.59 |
| Immaculate MagistrateDuels of the Planeswalkers · 70 | Duels of the Planeswalkers | 70 | Rare | €1.08 |
| Immaculate MagistrateGame Night: Free-for-All · 98 | Game Night: Free-for-All | 98 | Rare | €2.93 |
| Immaculate MagistrateLorwyn · 219 | Lorwyn | 219 | Rare | €1.39 |
| Immaculate MagistrateSalvat 2011 · 143 | Salvat 2011 | 143 | Rare | €1.32 |
| Immaculate MagistrateMagic Online Promos · 86048 | Magic Online Promos | 86048 | Rare | — |
| Immard, the StormcleaverUniverses Within · 14 | Universes Within | 14 | Rare | €0.23 |
| Immard, the StormcleaverSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 434 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 434 | Rare | €1.63 |
| Immersturm BattlefieldMystery Booster 2 Tokens · 564 | Mystery Booster 2 Tokens | 564 | Rare | $0.15 |
| Immersturm PredatorFoundations · 660 | Foundations | 660 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Immersturm PredatorKaldheim · 214 | Kaldheim | 214 | Rare | €0.23 |
| Immersturm PredatorKaldheim · 367 | Kaldheim | 367 | Rare | $0.64 |
| Immersturm PredatorKaldheim Promos · 214p | Kaldheim Promos | 214p | Rare | €0.26 |
| Immersturm PredatorKaldheim Promos · 214s | Kaldheim Promos | 214s | Rare | €1.14 |
| Immersturm PredatorMagic Online Promos · 88368 | Magic Online Promos | 88368 | Rare | — |
| ImmerwolfSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 809 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 809 | Rare | €3.04 |
| Imminent DoomHour of Devastation · 98 | Hour of Devastation | 98 | Rare | $0.13 |
| Imminent DoomHour of Devastation Promos · 98s | Hour of Devastation Promos | 98s | Rare | €0.34 |
| Imminent DoomAmonkhet Remastered · 161 | Amonkhet Remastered | 161 | Rare | — |
| Immolation ShamanRavnica Allegiance Promos · 106s | Ravnica Allegiance Promos | 106s | Rare | €0.62 |
| Immolation ShamanRavnica Allegiance · 106 | Ravnica Allegiance | 106 | Rare | €0.36 |
| Immoral BargainSecrets of Strixhaven Commander · 47 | Secrets of Strixhaven Commander | 47 | Rare | $0.56 |
| Immoral BargainSecrets of Strixhaven Commander · 95 | Secrets of Strixhaven Commander | 95 | Rare | €1.26 |
| Immortal CoilShards of Alara · 79 | Shards of Alara | 79 | Rare | €0.50 |
| Immortal ObligationMurders at Karlov Manor Commander · 10 | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander | 10 | Rare | €0.18 |
| Immortal ObligationMurders at Karlov Manor Commander · 321 | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander | 321 | Rare | €0.51 |