| Immortal PhoenixM19 Gift Pack · GP4 | M19 Gift Pack | GP4 | Rare | €0.43 |
| Immortal PhoenixCore Set 2020 · 332 | Core Set 2020 | 332 | Rare | €0.13 |
| Immortal PhoenixArena Beginner Set · 75 | Arena Beginner Set | 75 | Rare | — |
| Immortal PhoenixTreasure Chest · 70773 | Treasure Chest | 70773 | Rare | — |
| Immortal ServitudeGatecrash · 220 | Gatecrash | 220 | Rare | $0.40 |
| Immovable RodForgotten Realms Commander · 7 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 7 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Immovable RodForgotten Realms Commander · 276 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 276 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Imodane, the PyrohammerWilds of Eldraine Promos · 137p | Wilds of Eldraine Promos | 137p | Rare | €0.24 |
| Imodane, the PyrohammerWilds of Eldraine Promos · 137s | Wilds of Eldraine Promos | 137s | Rare | €0.92 |
| Imodane, the PyrohammerWilds of Eldraine · 137 | Wilds of Eldraine | 137 | Rare | €0.27 |
| Imodane, the PyrohammerWilds of Eldraine · 348 | Wilds of Eldraine | 348 | Rare | €0.43 |
| Imoen, Chaotic TricksterAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 7r | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 7r | Rare | — |
| Imoen, Honorable TricksterAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 7w | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 7w | Rare | — |
| Imoen, Occult TricksterAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 7b | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 7b | Rare | — |
| Imoen, Trickster FriendAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 7 | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 7 | Rare | — |
| Imoen, Wily TricksterAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 7u | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 7u | Rare | — |
| Imoen, Wise TricksterAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 7g | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 7g | Rare | — |
| Impact ResonanceCommander 2014 · 36 | Commander 2014 | 36 | Rare | €0.12 |
| Impact ResonanceCommander Anthology Volume II · 107 | Commander Anthology Volume II | 107 | Rare | €0.64 |
| Impact TremorsSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 313 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 313 | Rare | €9.34 |
| Impact TremorsSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1999 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1999 | Rare | $6.18 |
| ImpatienceSeventh Edition · 197 | Seventh Edition | 197 | Rare | $0.30 |
| ImpatienceSeventh Edition · 197★ | Seventh Edition | 197★ | Rare | $0.30 |
| ImpatienceUrza's Destiny · 88 | Urza's Destiny | 88 | Rare | $0.36 |
| Impatient IguanaMystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 · 55 | Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 | 55 | Rare | €0.39 |
| Impatient IguanaMystery Booster Playtest Cards 2021 · 55 | Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2021 | 55 | Rare | €0.45 |
| Impending DisasterThe List Tokens · ULG-82 | The List Tokens | ULG-82 | Rare | €0.42 |
| Impending DisasterUrza's Legacy · 82 | Urza's Legacy | 82 | Rare | €1.10 |
| Impending FluxDoctor Who · 87 | Doctor Who | 87 | Rare | €0.27 |
| Impending FluxDoctor Who · 386 | Doctor Who | 386 | Rare | €0.32 |
| Impending FluxDoctor Who · 692 | Doctor Who | 692 | Rare | €0.44 |
| Impending FluxDoctor Who · 977 | Doctor Who | 977 | Rare | €0.56 |
| Imperial BlademasterAlchemy: Kamigawa · 30 | Alchemy: Kamigawa | 30 | Rare | — |
| Imperial HellkiteArchenemy · 42 | Archenemy | 42 | Rare | $0.31 |
| Imperial HellkiteLegions · 103 | Legions | 103 | Rare | $0.42 |
| Imperial HellkiteMurders at Karlov Manor Commander · 155 | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander | 155 | Rare | €0.13 |
| Imperial MaskFuture Sight · 23 | Future Sight | 23 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Imperial RecruiterJudge Gift Cards 2013 Tokens · 3 | Judge Gift Cards 2013 Tokens | 3 | Rare | €56.95 |
| Imperial RecruiterMasters Edition II · 130 | Masters Edition II | 130 | Rare | — |
| Imperial RecruiterThe Zeta Set · 61 | The Zeta Set | 61 | Rare | — |
| Imperial RecruiterThe Zeta Set · 182 | The Zeta Set | 182 | Rare | — |
| Imperial RecruiterThe Zeta Set · 303 | The Zeta Set | 303 | Rare | — |
| Imperial SealJudge Gift Cards 2016 · 6 | Judge Gift Cards 2016 | 6 | Rare | $388.38 |
| Imperial SealPortal Three Kingdoms · 78 | Portal Three Kingdoms | 78 | Rare | €345.65 |
| Imperial SealMasters Edition II · 96 | Masters Edition II | 96 | Rare | — |
| Imperious MindbreakerCrimson Vow Commander · 33 | Crimson Vow Commander | 33 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Imperious MindbreakerCrimson Vow Commander · 71 | Crimson Vow Commander | 71 | Rare | €0.42 |
| Imperious MindbreakerMagic Online Promos · 95305 | Magic Online Promos | 95305 | Rare | — |
| Imperious PerfectEternal Masters · 173 | Eternal Masters | 173 | Rare | €0.47 |
| Imperious PerfectKaldheim Commander · 64 | Kaldheim Commander | 64 | Rare | €0.19 |