| Imperious PerfectJumpstart 2022 · 677 | Jumpstart 2022 | 677 | Rare | $0.56 |
| Imperious PerfectChamps and States · 9 | Champs and States | 9 | Rare | €9.71 |
| Impervious GreatwurmDouble Masters 2022 · 152 | Double Masters 2022 | 152 | Rare | €2.41 |
| Impervious GreatwurmDouble Masters 2022 · 463 | Double Masters 2022 | 463 | Rare | €6.36 |
| Impetuous DevilsEldritch Moon · 132 | Eldritch Moon | 132 | Rare | €0.16 |
| Impetuous DevilsEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 132s | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 132s | Rare | €0.28 |
| Implements of SacrificeFallen Empires · 88 | Fallen Empires | 88 | Rare | $0.75 |
| Imposing GrandeurCrimson Vow Commander · 24 | Crimson Vow Commander | 24 | Rare | €0.40 |
| Imposing GrandeurCrimson Vow Commander · 62 | Crimson Vow Commander | 62 | Rare | €0.50 |
| Imposing SovereignMagic 2014 · 22 | Magic 2014 | 22 | Rare | $0.40 |
| Imposter MechNeon Dynasty Commander · 13 | Neon Dynasty Commander | 13 | Rare | €2.60 |
| Imposter MechNeon Dynasty Commander · 49 | Neon Dynasty Commander | 49 | Rare | €0.57 |
| Imposter MechMagic Online Promos · 97919 | Magic Online Promos | 97919 | Rare | — |
| ImprisonLegends · 107 | Legends | 107 | Rare | €86.80 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonForgotten Realms Commander · 85 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 85 | Rare | $0.39 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonEldritch Moon · 65 | Eldritch Moon | 65 | Rare | $0.31 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonModern Horizons 3 Commander · 188 | Modern Horizons 3 Commander | 188 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonMarch of the Machine Commander · 224 | March of the Machine Commander | 224 | Rare | €0.24 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 65p | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 65p | Rare | €0.63 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 65s | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 65s | Rare | €2.17 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1102 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1102 | Rare | €8.43 |
| Imprisoned in the MoonCrimson Vow Commander · 106 | Crimson Vow Commander | 106 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Imprison This Insolent WretchDCI Promos · 58 | DCI Promos | 58 | Rare | €0.45 |
| Impromptu RaidShadowmoor · 209 | Shadowmoor | 209 | Rare | €0.21 |
| Improvised ArsenalTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles · 92 | Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles | 92 | Rare | €0.52 |
| Improvised ArsenalTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles · 270 | Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles | 270 | Rare | €1.09 |
| Imp's MischiefCommander Masters · 167 | Commander Masters | 167 | Rare | €6.98 |
| Imp's MischiefCommander Masters · 514 | Commander Masters | 514 | Rare | €19.08 |
| Imp's MischiefBreaking News · 15 | Breaking News | 15 | Rare | €5.10 |
| Imp's MischiefPlanar Chaos · 72 | Planar Chaos | 72 | Rare | €4.81 |
| Imp's MischiefThe Zeta Set · 45 | The Zeta Set | 45 | Rare | — |
| Imp's MischiefThe Zeta Set · 166 | The Zeta Set | 166 | Rare | — |
| Imp's MischiefThe Zeta Set · 287 | The Zeta Set | 287 | Rare | — |
| Imp's MischiefSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2555 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2555 | Rare | €6.93 |
| ImpulseFriday Night Magic 2001 · 11 | Friday Night Magic 2001 | 11 | Rare | €57.46 |
| Impulsive ManeuversOdyssey · 197 | Odyssey | 197 | Rare | €1.88 |
| Impulsive ManeuversThe List Tokens · ODY-197 | The List Tokens | ODY-197 | Rare | €2.92 |
| ImpulsivityLorwyn Eclipsed Commander · 13 | Lorwyn Eclipsed Commander | 13 | Rare | $0.25 |
| ImpulsivityLorwyn Eclipsed Commander · 33 | Lorwyn Eclipsed Commander | 33 | Rare | €0.30 |
| I'm Rubber, You're GlueUnglued · 5 | Unglued | 5 | Rare | €0.79 |
| Imskir Iron-EaterModern Horizons 3 · 189 | Modern Horizons 3 | 189 | Rare | €0.17 |
| Imskir Iron-EaterModern Horizons 3 · 374 | Modern Horizons 3 | 374 | Rare | €0.37 |
| Imskir Iron-EaterModern Horizons 3 · 431 | Modern Horizons 3 | 431 | Rare | €0.19 |
| Imskir Iron-EaterModern Horizons 3 · 488 | Modern Horizons 3 | 488 | Rare | €0.29 |
| Imskir Iron-EaterModern Horizons 3 Promos · 189s | Modern Horizons 3 Promos | 189s | Rare | $0.49 |
| Inalla, Archmage RitualistFinal Fantasy: Through the Ages · 52 | Final Fantasy: Through the Ages | 52 | Rare | €1.06 |
| Iname as OneSaviors of Kamigawa · 151 | Saviors of Kamigawa | 151 | Rare | €0.73 |
| Iname, Death AspectChampions of Kamigawa · 118 | Champions of Kamigawa | 118 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Iname, Life AspectChampions of Kamigawa · 215 | Champions of Kamigawa | 215 | Rare | €0.34 |
| Incandescent AriaStreets of New Capenna Promos · 192p | Streets of New Capenna Promos | 192p | Rare | €0.13 |