| Incandescent AriaStreets of New Capenna Promos · 192s | Streets of New Capenna Promos | 192s | Rare | $0.42 |
| Incandescent AriaStreets of New Capenna · 192 | Streets of New Capenna | 192 | Rare | €0.13 |
| Incandescent AriaStreets of New Capenna · 311 | Streets of New Capenna | 311 | Rare | €0.13 |
| Incandescent AriaStreets of New Capenna · 376 | Streets of New Capenna | 376 | Rare | €0.02 |
| Incandescent SoulstokeLorwyn · 178 | Lorwyn | 178 | Rare | €0.48 |
| Incarnation TechniqueCommander 2021 · 41 | Commander 2021 | 41 | Rare | $9.14 |
| Incarnation TechniqueCommander 2021 · 368 | Commander 2021 | 368 | Rare | €4.50 |
| Incarnation TechniqueSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1776 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1776 | Rare | $9.29 |
| Incarnation TechniqueMagic Online Promos · 90084 | Magic Online Promos | 90084 | Rare | — |
| Incendiary CommandCommander 2013 · 113 | Commander 2013 | 113 | Rare | €0.19 |
| Incendiary CommandLorwyn · 179 | Lorwyn | 179 | Rare | €0.96 |
| Incendiary FlowFriday Night Magic 2017 Tokens · 3 | Friday Night Magic 2017 Tokens | 3 | Rare | €0.21 |
| Inchblade CompanionAlchemy: Kamigawa · 2 | Alchemy: Kamigawa | 2 | Rare | — |
| IncinerateOversized League Prizes · 43 | Oversized League Prizes | 43 | Rare | €30.92 |
| IncinerateMagic Player Rewards 2008 · 3 | Magic Player Rewards 2008 | 3 | Rare | €0.52 |
| IncinerateDCI Legend Membership · 2 | DCI Legend Membership | 2 | Rare | €3.85 |
| Incite InsightThe List (Unfinity Foil Edition) · 16 | The List (Unfinity Foil Edition) | 16 | Rare | $0.10 |
| Incite InsightUnstable · 36 | Unstable | 36 | Rare | €0.11 |
| Incite RebellionCommander 2014 · 37 | Commander 2014 | 37 | Rare | €0.19 |
| Incite RebellionCommander Anthology Volume II · 108 | Commander Anthology Volume II | 108 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Incoming!Oversized 90's Promos · 10 | Oversized 90's Promos | 10 | Rare | €6.36 |
| Incoming!Unglued · 64 | Unglued | 64 | Rare | $1.37 |
| Increasing AmbitionDark Ascension · 69 | Dark Ascension | 69 | Rare | €1.61 |
| Increasing AmbitionShadows of the Past · 32 | Shadows of the Past | 32 | Rare | — |
| Increasing ConfusionDark Ascension · 41 | Dark Ascension | 41 | Rare | $0.93 |
| Increasing DevotionCommander 2019 · 66 | Commander 2019 | 66 | Rare | €0.23 |
| Increasing DevotionCommander 2020 · 91 | Commander 2020 | 91 | Rare | €0.17 |
| Increasing DevotionDuel Decks: Blessed vs. Cursed Tokens · 14 | Duel Decks: Blessed vs. Cursed Tokens | 14 | Rare | €0.21 |
| Increasing DevotionDark Ascension · 11 | Dark Ascension | 11 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Increasing DevotionTales of Middle-earth Commander · 171 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 171 | Rare | €0.24 |
| Increasing DevotionPhyrexia: All Will Be One Commander · 76 | Phyrexia: All Will Be One Commander | 76 | Rare | €0.16 |
| Increasing SavageryDuel Decks: Mind vs. Might · 47 | Duel Decks: Mind vs. Might | 47 | Rare | $0.40 |
| Increasing SavageryDark Ascension · 120 | Dark Ascension | 120 | Rare | $0.43 |
| Increasing VengeanceCommander 2019 · 147 | Commander 2019 | 147 | Rare | €0.28 |
| Increasing VengeanceDark Ascension · 95 | Dark Ascension | 95 | Rare | $0.83 |
| Incubation DruidCommander 2021 · 195 | Commander 2021 | 195 | Rare | €1.70 |
| Incubation DruidFinal Fantasy Commander · 309 | Final Fantasy Commander | 309 | Rare | $0.77 |
| Incubation DruidMarch of the Machine Commander · 302 | March of the Machine Commander | 302 | Rare | €1.50 |
| Incubation DruidNew Capenna Commander · 296 | New Capenna Commander | 296 | Rare | €2.17 |
| Incubation DruidRavnica Allegiance Promos · 131p | Ravnica Allegiance Promos | 131p | Rare | $1.84 |
| Incubation DruidRavnica Allegiance Promos · 131s | Ravnica Allegiance Promos | 131s | Rare | €3.21 |
| Incubation DruidRavnica Allegiance · 131 | Ravnica Allegiance | 131 | Rare | €1.28 |
| Incubation TriformerUnknown Event · RB03c | Unknown Event | RB03c | Rare | $0.24 |
| Indatha TriomeIkoria: Lair of Behemoths · 248 | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths | 248 | Rare | €17.00 |
| Indatha TriomeIkoria: Lair of Behemoths · 309 | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths | 309 | Rare | €16.84 |
| Indatha TriomeIkoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos · 248p | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos | 248p | Rare | €15.92 |
| Indatha TriomeIkoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos · 248s | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos | 248s | Rare | €19.01 |
| Indatha TriomeMagic Online Promos · 80945 | Magic Online Promos | 80945 | Rare | — |
| IndestructibilityMagic 2010 · 17 | Magic 2010 | 17 | Rare | €1.11 |
| IndestructibilityMagic 2014 · 23 | Magic 2014 | 23 | Rare | €0.70 |