| IndicateMystery Booster 2 Tokens · 501 | Mystery Booster 2 Tokens | 501 | Rare | $0.41 |
| Indominus Rex, AlphaJurassic World Collection · 14 | Jurassic World Collection | 14 | Rare | €19.24 |
| Indominus Rex, AlphaJurassic World Collection · 39 | Jurassic World Collection | 39 | Rare | €702.25 |
| Indomitable AncientsMorningtide · 13 | Morningtide | 13 | Rare | €1.73 |
| Indomitable AncientsTarkir: Dragonstorm Commander · 121 | Tarkir: Dragonstorm Commander | 121 | Rare | $0.35 |
| Indomitable ArchangelModern Masters 2015 · 19 | Modern Masters 2015 | 19 | Rare | $0.36 |
| Indomitable MightForgotten Realms Commander · 40 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 40 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Indomitable MightForgotten Realms Commander · 309 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 309 | Rare | €0.40 |
| Indomitable MightWilds of Eldraine Commander · 127 | Wilds of Eldraine Commander | 127 | Rare | €0.44 |
| Indoraptor, the Perfect HybridJurassic World Collection · 15 | Jurassic World Collection | 15 | Rare | €16.84 |
| Indoraptor, the Perfect HybridJurassic World Collection · 40 | Jurassic World Collection | 40 | Rare | €419.92 |
| Indrik UmbraPlanechase Anthology · 96 | Planechase Anthology | 96 | Rare | €0.39 |
| Indrik UmbraPlanechase 2012 · 96 | Planechase 2012 | 96 | Rare | €0.35 |
| Induced AmnesiaRivals of Ixalan Promos · 40s | Rivals of Ixalan Promos | 40s | Rare | €0.91 |
| Induced AmnesiaRivals of Ixalan · 40 | Rivals of Ixalan | 40 | Rare | €0.19 |
| Indulge // ExcessNew Capenna Commander · 46 | New Capenna Commander | 46 | Rare | $0.46 |
| Indulge // ExcessNew Capenna Commander Promos · 46p | New Capenna Commander Promos | 46p | Rare | €7.05 |
| Indulgent TormentorDuel Decks: Nissa vs. Ob Nixilis Tokens · 53 | Duel Decks: Nissa vs. Ob Nixilis Tokens | 53 | Rare | $0.55 |
| Indulgent TormentorMagic 2015 · 101 | Magic 2015 | 101 | Rare | €0.52 |
| Indulgent TormentorMagic 2015 Promos · 101 | Magic 2015 Promos | 101 | Rare | €0.84 |
| Indulgent TormentorMagic Online Promos · 53822 | Magic Online Promos | 53822 | Rare | — |
| Industrial AdvancementNew Capenna Commander · 47 | New Capenna Commander | 47 | Rare | €0.87 |
| Industrial AdvancementNew Capenna Commander · 147 | New Capenna Commander | 147 | Rare | $5.19 |
| Industrial AdvancementNew Capenna Commander Promos · 47p | New Capenna Commander Promos | 47p | Rare | €2.70 |
| Ineffable BlessingThe List (Unfinity Foil Edition) · 37 | The List (Unfinity Foil Edition) | 37 | Rare | $0.20 |
| Ineffable BlessingThe List (Unfinity Foil Edition) · 38 | The List (Unfinity Foil Edition) | 38 | Rare | $0.35 |
| Ineffable BlessingUnstable · 113a | Unstable | 113a | Rare | $0.69 |
| Ineffable BlessingUnstable · 113b | Unstable | 113b | Rare | $0.56 |
| Ineffable BlessingUnstable · 113c | Unstable | 113c | Rare | $1.15 |
| Ineffable BlessingUnstable · 113d | Unstable | 113d | Rare | $1.10 |
| Ineffable BlessingUnstable · 113e | Unstable | 113e | Rare | $0.77 |
| Ineffable BlessingUnstable · 113f | Unstable | 113f | Rare | $0.78 |
| Inevitable BetrayalModern Horizons 2 · 47 | Modern Horizons 2 | 47 | Rare | €0.59 |
| Inevitable BetrayalModern Horizons 2 · 390 | Modern Horizons 2 | 390 | Rare | €0.94 |
| Inevitable BetrayalModern Horizons 2 · 446 | Modern Horizons 2 | 446 | Rare | €0.69 |
| Inevitable BetrayalModern Horizons 2 Promos · 47s | Modern Horizons 2 Promos | 47s | Rare | $1.52 |
| Inevitable BetrayalSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1935 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1935 | Rare | €3.14 |
| Inevitable BetrayalMagic Online Promos · 91239 | Magic Online Promos | 91239 | Rare | — |
| Inevitable DefeatTarkir: Dragonstorm Promos · 194p | Tarkir: Dragonstorm Promos | 194p | Rare | €0.26 |
| Inevitable DefeatTarkir: Dragonstorm Promos · 194s | Tarkir: Dragonstorm Promos | 194s | Rare | €1.31 |
| Inevitable DefeatTarkir: Dragonstorm · 194 | Tarkir: Dragonstorm | 194 | Rare | €0.31 |
| Inevitable DefeatTarkir: Dragonstorm · 360 | Tarkir: Dragonstorm | 360 | Rare | €0.36 |
| Inexorable BlobShadows over Innistrad Promos · 212s | Shadows over Innistrad Promos | 212s | Rare | €0.44 |
| Inexorable BlobShadows over Innistrad · 212 | Shadows over Innistrad | 212 | Rare | €0.18 |
| Inexorable TideFinal Fantasy Commander · 265 | Final Fantasy Commander | 265 | Rare | $0.85 |
| Inexorable TideModern Masters 2015 · 49 | Modern Masters 2015 | 49 | Rare | €2.42 |
| Inexorable TideFallout · 177 | Fallout | 177 | Rare | €1.73 |
| Inexorable TideFallout · 460 | Fallout | 460 | Rare | €3.41 |
| Inexorable TideFallout · 705 | Fallout | 705 | Rare | €3.99 |
| Inexorable TideFallout · 988 | Fallout | 988 | Rare | €5.80 |