| Inspiring RefrainMagic Online Promos · 90034 | Magic Online Promos | 90034 | Rare | — |
| Inspiring StatuaryAether Revolt · 160 | Aether Revolt | 160 | Rare | €0.35 |
| Inspiring StatuaryThe Brothers' War Retro Artifacts · 22 | The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts | 22 | Rare | €0.32 |
| Inspiring StatuaryThe Brothers' War Retro Artifacts · 85 | The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts | 85 | Rare | €0.70 |
| Inspiring StatuaryThe Brothers' War Retro Artifacts · 85z | The Brothers' War Retro Artifacts | 85z | Rare | €210.70 |
| Inspiring StatuaryCommander Masters · 394 | Commander Masters | 394 | Rare | €0.35 |
| Inspiring StatuaryCommander Masters · 609 | Commander Masters | 609 | Rare | €3.52 |
| Inspiring StatuaryFinal Fantasy Commander · 347 | Final Fantasy Commander | 347 | Rare | $0.26 |
| Inspiring StatuaryMurders at Karlov Manor Commander · 230 | Murders at Karlov Manor Commander | 230 | Rare | €0.41 |
| Inspiring StatuaryMarch of the Machine Commander · 361 | March of the Machine Commander | 361 | Rare | $0.42 |
| Inspiring StatuaryAether Revolt Promos · 160s | Aether Revolt Promos | 160s | Rare | $1.64 |
| Inspiring StatuaryHistoric Anthology 4 · 23 | Historic Anthology 4 | 23 | Rare | — |
| Inspiring VantageKaladesh · 246 | Kaladesh | 246 | Rare | €2.17 |
| Inspiring VantageOutlaws of Thunder Junction · 269 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction | 269 | Rare | $2.17 |
| Inspiring VantageOutlaws of Thunder Junction · 303 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction | 303 | Rare | €2.72 |
| Inspiring VantageKaladesh Promos · 246s | Kaladesh Promos | 246s | Rare | €2.84 |
| Inspiring VantageOutlaws of Thunder Junction Promos · 269p | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Promos | 269p | Rare | €1.90 |
| Inspiring VantageOutlaws of Thunder Junction Promos · 269s | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Promos | 269s | Rare | €2.33 |
| Inspiring VantageSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1375 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1375 | Rare | €4.57 |
| Inspiring VantageSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1605 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1605 | Rare | €10.51 |
| Inspiring VantageSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1605★ | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1605★ | Rare | $20.39 |
| Inspiring VantageKaladesh Remastered · 283 | Kaladesh Remastered | 283 | Rare | — |
| InstigatorMercadian Masques · 140 | Mercadian Masques | 140 | Rare | €0.27 |
| Instigator Gang // Wildblood PackInnistrad · 149 | Innistrad | 149 | Rare | $0.74 |
| Instrument of the BardsAdventures in the Forgotten Realms · 190 | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms | 190 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Instrument of the BardsAdventures in the Forgotten Realms · 385 | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms | 385 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Instrument of the BardsAdventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos · 190a | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos | 190a | Rare | €1.06 |
| Instrument of the BardsAdventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos · 190p | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos | 190p | Rare | €0.40 |
| Instrument of the BardsAdventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos · 190s | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos | 190s | Rare | €0.57 |
| Instrument of the BardsMagic Online Promos · 92776 | Magic Online Promos | 92776 | Rare | — |
| Insult // InjuryAmonkhet · 213 | Amonkhet | 213 | Rare | €0.60 |
| Insult // InjuryAmonkhet Promos · 213s | Amonkhet Promos | 213s | Rare | €1.74 |
| Insult // InjuryThe List Tokens · AKH-213 | The List Tokens | AKH-213 | Rare | €0.34 |
| Insult // InjuryAmonkhet Remastered · 162 | Amonkhet Remastered | 162 | Rare | — |
| InsurrectionCommander 2011 · 126 | Commander 2011 | 126 | Rare | €4.00 |
| InsurrectionPlanechase · 57 | Planechase | 57 | Rare | €6.00 |
| InsurrectionOnslaught · 213 | Onslaught | 213 | Rare | €7.84 |
| Intangible VibesMystery Booster 2 Tokens · 516 | Mystery Booster 2 Tokens | 516 | Rare | $0.18 |
| Intellect DevourerCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 132 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 132 | Rare | €0.32 |
| Intellect DevourerCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 575 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 575 | Rare | $0.37 |
| Intellect DevourerBattle for Baldur's Gate Promos · 132s | Battle for Baldur's Gate Promos | 132s | Rare | €0.52 |
| Intellect DevourerAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 162 | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 162 | Rare | — |
| Intellectual OfferingBloomburrow Commander · 168 | Bloomburrow Commander | 168 | Rare | €0.28 |
| Intellectual OfferingCommander 2014 · 15 | Commander 2014 | 15 | Rare | €0.29 |
| Interceptor, Shadow's HoundFinal Fantasy Commander · 47 | Final Fantasy Commander | 47 | Rare | $0.16 |
| Interceptor, Shadow's HoundFinal Fantasy Commander · 147 | Final Fantasy Commander | 147 | Rare | $0.43 |
| Interdimensional Web WatchMarvel's Spider-Man Promos · 165s | Marvel's Spider-Man Promos | 165s | Rare | $1.33 |
| Interdimensional Web WatchMarvel's Spider-Man · 165 | Marvel's Spider-Man | 165 | Rare | €0.22 |
| Interdimensional Web WatchMarvel's Spider-Man · 278 | Marvel's Spider-Man | 278 | Rare | $0.49 |
| Interdimensional Web WatchThrough the Omenpaths · 172 | Through the Omenpaths | 172 | Rare | — |