| Pinchy McStingbuttMystery Booster 2 Tokens · 552 | Mystery Booster 2 Tokens | 552 | Rare | €0.14 |
| Pine BarrensTempest · 321 | Tempest | 321 | Rare | €1.26 |
| Pink HorrorWarhammer 40,000 Commander · 136 | Warhammer 40,000 Commander | 136 | Rare | $0.58 |
| Pink HorrorWarhammer 40,000 Commander · 136★ | Warhammer 40,000 Commander | 136★ | Rare | $2.81 |
| Pinnacle EmissaryEdge of Eternities · 223 | Edge of Eternities | 223 | Rare | $1.39 |
| Pinnacle EmissaryEdge of Eternities · 349 | Edge of Eternities | 349 | Rare | $2.72 |
| Pinnacle EmissaryEdge of Eternities Promos · 223p | Edge of Eternities Promos | 223p | Rare | $1.37 |
| Pinnacle EmissaryEdge of Eternities Promos · 223s | Edge of Eternities Promos | 223s | Rare | €3.96 |
| Pinnacle StarcageEdge of Eternities · 27 | Edge of Eternities | 27 | Rare | €0.32 |
| Pinnacle StarcageEdge of Eternities · 322 | Edge of Eternities | 322 | Rare | $0.46 |
| Pinnacle StarcageEdge of Eternities Promos · 27p | Edge of Eternities Promos | 27p | Rare | $0.32 |
| Pinnacle StarcageEdge of Eternities Promos · 27s | Edge of Eternities Promos | 27s | Rare | €0.67 |
| Pinnacle StarcageSecret Lair Promo · 54 | Secret Lair Promo | 54 | Rare | $1.95 |
| Pip-Boy 3000Fallout · 140 | Fallout | 140 | Rare | €4.23 |
| Pip-Boy 3000Fallout · 435 | Fallout | 435 | Rare | €4.94 |
| Pip-Boy 3000Fallout · 668 | Fallout | 668 | Rare | €12.44 |
| Pip-Boy 3000Fallout · 963 | Fallout | 963 | Rare | €9.75 |
| Piper of the SwarmForgotten Realms Commander · 106 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 106 | Rare | €0.91 |
| Piper of the SwarmThrone of Eldraine · 100 | Throne of Eldraine | 100 | Rare | €0.45 |
| Piper of the SwarmThrone of Eldraine · 355 | Throne of Eldraine | 355 | Rare | €1.74 |
| Piper of the SwarmThrone of Eldraine · 392 | Throne of Eldraine | 392 | Rare | $0.47 |
| Piper of the SwarmThrone of Eldraine Promos · 100p | Throne of Eldraine Promos | 100p | Rare | €0.65 |
| Piper of the SwarmThrone of Eldraine Promos · 100s | Throne of Eldraine Promos | 100s | Rare | €1.92 |
| Piper of the SwarmSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 7074 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 7074 | Rare | $3.48 |
| Piper of the SwarmMagic Online Promos · 78862 | Magic Online Promos | 78862 | Rare | — |
| Piper Wright, Publick ReporterFallout · 36 | Fallout | 36 | Rare | €0.33 |
| Piper Wright, Publick ReporterFallout · 379 | Fallout | 379 | Rare | €0.53 |
| Piper Wright, Publick ReporterFallout · 564 | Fallout | 564 | Rare | €2.53 |
| Piper Wright, Publick ReporterFallout · 907 | Fallout | 907 | Rare | €2.31 |
| Pippa, Duchess of DiceThe List (Unfinity Foil Edition) · 40 | The List (Unfinity Foil Edition) | 40 | Rare | $0.25 |
| Pippa, Duchess of DiceUnsanctioned · 68 | Unsanctioned | 68 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Pippin, Guard of the CitadelThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth · 218 | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth | 218 | Rare | $0.61 |
| Pippin, Guard of the CitadelThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth · 326 | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth | 326 | Rare | $0.73 |
| Pippin, Guard of the CitadelThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth · 438 | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth | 438 | Rare | $1.62 |
| Pippin, Guard of the CitadelThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth · 669 | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth | 669 | Rare | $2.74 |
| Pippin, Guard of the CitadelThe Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth · 818 | The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth | 818 | Rare | €8.30 |
| Pippin, Guard of the CitadelTales of Middle-earth Promos · 218s | Tales of Middle-earth Promos | 218s | Rare | €3.39 |
| Pippin, Warden of IsengardTales of Middle-earth Commander · 65 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 65 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Pippin, Warden of IsengardTales of Middle-earth Commander · 146 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 146 | Rare | $3.37 |
| Pippin, Warden of IsengardTales of Middle-earth Commander · 472 | Tales of Middle-earth Commander | 472 | Rare | $6.62 |
| PiracyPortal Second Age · 42 | Portal Second Age | 42 | Rare | €21.16 |
| PiracyStarter 1999 · 45 | Starter 1999 | 45 | Rare | €56.62 |
| Pirate ShipUnlimited Edition · 71 | Unlimited Edition | 71 | Rare | $13.62 |
| Pirate ShipRevised Edition · 72 | Revised Edition | 72 | Rare | €0.86 |
| Pirate Ship30th Anniversary Edition · 70 | 30th Anniversary Edition | 70 | Rare | €14.64 |
| Pirate Ship30th Anniversary Edition · 367 | 30th Anniversary Edition | 367 | Rare | €14.64 |
| Pirate ShipFourth Edition Foreign Black Border · 91 | Fourth Edition Foreign Black Border | 91 | Rare | €4.92 |
| Pirate ShipFourth Edition · 91 | Fourth Edition | 91 | Rare | $0.45 |
| Pirate ShipFifth Edition · 109 | Fifth Edition | 109 | Rare | €0.54 |
| Pirate ShipCollectors' Edition · 71 | Collectors' Edition | 71 | Rare | €2.79 |