| Pirate ShipIntl. Collectors' Edition · 71 | Intl. Collectors' Edition | 71 | Rare | €2.10 |
| Pirate ShipForeign Black Border · 72 | Foreign Black Border | 72 | Rare | €2.41 |
| Pirate ShipLimited Edition Alpha · 70 | Limited Edition Alpha | 70 | Rare | €611.18 |
| Pirate ShipLimited Edition Beta · 71 | Limited Edition Beta | 71 | Rare | €161.41 |
| Pirate ShipSummer Magic / Edgar · 72 | Summer Magic / Edgar | 72 | Rare | €747.66 |
| Pir, Imaginative RascalBattlebond · 11 | Battlebond | 11 | Rare | $4.28 |
| Pir, Imaginative RascalBattlebond Promos · 11s | Battlebond Promos | 11s | Rare | €7.60 |
| Pir, Imaginative RascalSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1050 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1050 | Rare | €7.71 |
| Pir, Imaginative RascalThe List Tokens · BBD-11 | The List Tokens | BBD-11 | Rare | €3.00 |
| Pirk, Heroic CaptainUnknown Event · RZ03n | Unknown Event | RZ03n | Rare | — |
| Pir's WhimBattlebond · 73 | Battlebond | 73 | Rare | €1.75 |
| Pir's WhimThe List Tokens · BBD-73 | The List Tokens | BBD-73 | Rare | €2.09 |
| Piru, the VolatileModern Horizons 2 · 207 | Modern Horizons 2 | 207 | Rare | €0.20 |
| Piru, the VolatileModern Horizons 2 · 422 | Modern Horizons 2 | 422 | Rare | $0.28 |
| Piru, the VolatileModern Horizons 2 · 466 | Modern Horizons 2 | 466 | Rare | $0.43 |
| Piru, the VolatileModern Horizons 2 Promos · 207s | Modern Horizons 2 Promos | 207s | Rare | €1.11 |
| Piru, the VolatileMagic Online Promos · 91347 | Magic Online Promos | 91347 | Rare | — |
| Pithing NeedleDouble Masters 2022 · 312 | Double Masters 2022 | 312 | Rare | $0.48 |
| Pithing NeedleTenth Edition · 338 | Tenth Edition | 338 | Rare | €0.67 |
| Pithing NeedleDouble Masters 2022 · 397 | Double Masters 2022 | 397 | Rare | $1.48 |
| Pithing NeedleDouble Masters 2022 · 564 | Double Masters 2022 | 564 | Rare | €2.61 |
| Pithing NeedleInnistrad: Double Feature · 257 | Innistrad: Double Feature | 257 | Rare | €0.63 |
| Pithing NeedleMagic 2010 · 217 | Magic 2010 | 217 | Rare | $0.56 |
| Pithing NeedleInnistrad: Midnight Hunt · 257 | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt | 257 | Rare | €0.35 |
| Pithing NeedleInnistrad: Midnight Hunt · 378 | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt | 378 | Rare | $0.53 |
| Pithing NeedleInnistrad: Midnight Hunt Promos · 257p | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt Promos | 257p | Rare | $0.43 |
| Pithing NeedleInnistrad: Midnight Hunt Promos · 257s | Innistrad: Midnight Hunt Promos | 257s | Rare | €1.55 |
| Pithing NeedleReturn to Ravnica · 231 | Return to Ravnica | 231 | Rare | €0.55 |
| Pithing NeedleSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 44 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 44 | Rare | €3.60 |
| Pithing NeedleRavnica Remastered · 463 | Ravnica Remastered | 463 | Rare | $1.66 |
| Pithing NeedleSaviors of Kamigawa · 158 | Saviors of Kamigawa | 158 | Rare | €1.64 |
| Pithing NeedleMagic Online Promos · 94084 | Magic Online Promos | 94084 | Rare | — |
| Pithing NeedleMagic Online Promos · 102335 | Magic Online Promos | 102335 | Rare | — |
| Pithing SpyglassMystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 · 108 | Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 | 108 | Rare | $0.61 |
| Pithing SpyglassMystery Booster Playtest Cards 2021 · 108 | Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2021 | 108 | Rare | €0.23 |
| Pitiless CarnageOutlaws of Thunder Junction · 98 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction | 98 | Rare | €0.22 |
| Pitiless CarnageOutlaws of Thunder Junction · 326 | Outlaws of Thunder Junction | 326 | Rare | $0.74 |
| Pitiless CarnageOutlaws of Thunder Junction Promos · 98p | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Promos | 98p | Rare | €0.36 |
| Pitiless CarnageOutlaws of Thunder Junction Promos · 98s | Outlaws of Thunder Junction Promos | 98s | Rare | $0.63 |
| Pitiless HordeDragons of Tarkir · 112 | Dragons of Tarkir | 112 | Rare | $0.15 |
| Pitiless HordeDragons of Tarkir Promos · 112s | Dragons of Tarkir Promos | 112s | Rare | €0.06 |
| Pitiless HordeThe List Tokens · DTK-112 | The List Tokens | DTK-112 | Rare | €0.15 |
| Pitiless PlundererSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1431 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1431 | Rare | €16.09 |
| Pit SpawnExodus · 70 | Exodus | 70 | Rare | $0.48 |
| Pixie QueenLegends · 196 | Legends | 196 | Rare | €32.90 |
| PlagiarizeTenth Edition · 97 | Tenth Edition | 97 | Rare | $0.46 |
| PlagiarizeNinth Edition · 89 | Ninth Edition | 89 | Rare | $0.40 |
| PlagiarizeNinth Edition · 89★ | Ninth Edition | 89★ | Rare | $0.40 |
| PlagiarizeTorment · 44 | Torment | 44 | Rare | $0.36 |
| Plagon, Lord of the BeachFoundations Jumpstart · 37 | Foundations Jumpstart | 37 | Rare | $0.96 |