| Polukranos Reborn // Polukranos, Engine of RuinMarch of the Machine Promos · 200s | March of the Machine Promos | 200s | Rare | €0.79 |
| Polukranos, World EaterPioneer Masters · 190 | Pioneer Masters | 190 | Rare | — |
| PolygoyfModern Horizons 3 Commander · 65 | Modern Horizons 3 Commander | 65 | Rare | $0.40 |
| PolygoyfModern Horizons 3 Commander · 117 | Modern Horizons 3 Commander | 117 | Rare | €0.14 |
| PolymorphClassic Sixth Edition · 86 | Classic Sixth Edition | 86 | Rare | €2.22 |
| PolymorphNinth Edition · 90 | Ninth Edition | 90 | Rare | €1.24 |
| PolymorphNinth Edition · 90★ | Ninth Edition | 90★ | Rare | $1.76 |
| PolymorphMagic 2010 · 67 | Magic 2010 | 67 | Rare | €2.00 |
| PolymorphMirage · 82 | Mirage | 82 | Rare | €2.68 |
| PolymorphThe List Tokens · M10-67 | The List Tokens | M10-67 | Rare | $2.90 |
| Polymorphist's JestCommander 2017 · 90 | Commander 2017 | 90 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Polymorphist's JestMagic 2015 · 75 | Magic 2015 | 75 | Rare | €4.34 |
| Polymorphous RushJourney into Nyx · 46 | Journey into Nyx | 46 | Rare | €0.22 |
| Pompous Battlemage // Improvised ActReality Fracture · 90 | Reality Fracture | 90 | Rare | $0.81 |
| Pompous Battlemage // Improvised ActReality Fracture · 428 | Reality Fracture | 428 | Rare | $0.73 |
| Pompous Battlemage // Improvised ActReality Fracture Promos · 90p | Reality Fracture Promos | 90p | Rare | $2.03 |
| PonderMagic Player Rewards 2008 · 6 | Magic Player Rewards 2008 | 6 | Rare | €8.44 |
| PonderEternal Weekend · 2022b | Eternal Weekend | 2022b | Rare | — |
| PonderMagicFest 2025 · 2 | MagicFest 2025 | 2 | Rare | $7.18 |
| PonderSecret Lair Countdown · 2007 | Secret Lair Countdown | 2007 | Rare | €8.90 |
| PonderSecret Lair Promo · 19 | Secret Lair Promo | 19 | Rare | €4.90 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 245 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 245 | Rare | $6.48 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1783 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1783 | Rare | $18.11 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2292 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2292 | Rare | $7.10 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2670 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2670 | Rare | $3.01 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 7119 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 7119 | Rare | $68.88 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 7122 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 7122 | Rare | $2.64 |
| PonderSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 7125 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 7125 | Rare | €1.78 |
| PongifySecrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive · 20 | Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 20 | Rare | €2.99 |
| PongifySecrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive · 85 | Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 85 | Rare | €5.57 |
| PongifySecrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive · 150 | Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 150 | Rare | €22.62 |
| Pontiff of BlightForgotten Realms Commander · 108 | Forgotten Realms Commander | 108 | Rare | €0.14 |
| Pontiff of BlightCommander 2014 · 155 | Commander 2014 | 155 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Pontiff of BlightCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 768 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 768 | Rare | €0.10 |
| Pontiff of BlightDragon's Maze · 27 | Dragon's Maze | 27 | Rare | €0.26 |
| Pontiff of BlightRNA Guild Kit · 33 | RNA Guild Kit | 33 | Rare | $0.34 |
| Pontiff of BlightSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 848 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 848 | Rare | €10.35 |
| Pool of Vigorous GrowthJumpstart: Historic Horizons · 28 | Jumpstart: Historic Horizons | 28 | Rare | — |
| Popular EntertainerCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 192 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 192 | Rare | €0.13 |
| Popular EntertainerCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 509 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 509 | Rare | €0.15 |
| Popular EntertainerBattle for Baldur's Gate Promos · 192s | Battle for Baldur's Gate Promos | 192s | Rare | €0.20 |
| Porcine Portent // Lend a HamAlchemy: Wilds of Eldraine · 23 | Alchemy: Wilds of Eldraine | 23 | Rare | — |
| Porphyry NodesPlanar Chaos · 28 | Planar Chaos | 28 | Rare | €0.25 |
| Porphyry NodesTime Spiral Remastered · 32 | Time Spiral Remastered | 32 | Rare | €0.22 |
| Portal MageCommander 2017 · 13 | Commander 2017 | 13 | Rare | $0.25 |
| Portal MageCommander 2020 · 122 | Commander 2020 | 122 | Rare | €0.21 |
| PortcullisStronghold · 139 | Stronghold | 139 | Rare | €1.01 |
| Portent of CalamityBloomburrow · 66 | Bloomburrow | 66 | Rare | $0.26 |
| Portent of CalamityBloomburrow · 306 | Bloomburrow | 306 | Rare | $0.45 |
| Portent of CalamityBloomburrow Promos · 66p | Bloomburrow Promos | 66p | Rare | €0.39 |