| Puresteel PaladinFinal Fantasy Commander · 250 | Final Fantasy Commander | 250 | Rare | $0.49 |
| Puresteel PaladinNew Phyrexia · 20 | New Phyrexia | 20 | Rare | €1.19 |
| Puresteel PaladinFallout · 170 | Fallout | 170 | Rare | $0.91 |
| Puresteel PaladinFallout · 456 | Fallout | 456 | Rare | €2.27 |
| Puresteel PaladinFallout · 698 | Fallout | 698 | Rare | €5.19 |
| Puresteel PaladinThe List Tokens · NPH-20 | The List Tokens | NPH-20 | Rare | €1.58 |
| Puresteel PaladinFallout · 984 | Fallout | 984 | Rare | €6.41 |
| Puresteel PaladinSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1352 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1352 | Rare | €22.88 |
| PurgatoryMirage · 275 | Mirage | 275 | Rare | $1.54 |
| Purging ScytheUrza's Saga · 308 | Urza's Saga | 308 | Rare | $0.41 |
| PurifySeventh Edition · 31 | Seventh Edition | 31 | Rare | €0.34 |
| PurifySeventh Edition · 31★ | Seventh Edition | 31★ | Rare | $0.43 |
| PurifyUrza's Legacy · 19 | Urza's Legacy | 19 | Rare | $0.41 |
| PurityLorwyn · 37 | Lorwyn | 37 | Rare | €1.16 |
| Purphoros, God of the ForgeJudge Gift Cards 2022 · 8 | Judge Gift Cards 2022 | 8 | Rare | €28.41 |
| Purphoros's InterventionTheros Beyond Death Promos · 151p | Theros Beyond Death Promos | 151p | Rare | €0.23 |
| Purphoros's InterventionTheros Beyond Death Promos · 151s | Theros Beyond Death Promos | 151s | Rare | €0.45 |
| Purphoros's InterventionTheros Beyond Death · 151 | Theros Beyond Death | 151 | Rare | $0.20 |
| Purphoros's InterventionTheros Beyond Death · 320 | Theros Beyond Death | 320 | Rare | €0.37 |
| Purphoros's InterventionMagic Online Promos · 79899 | Magic Online Promos | 79899 | Rare | — |
| Purraj of UrborgMirage · 135 | Mirage | 135 | Rare | $0.97 |
| Pursued WhaleCommander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 732 | Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate | 732 | Rare | €0.14 |
| Pursued WhaleCore Set 2021 · 60 | Core Set 2021 | 60 | Rare | €0.09 |
| Pursued WhaleCore Set 2021 · 351 | Core Set 2021 | 351 | Rare | $0.29 |
| Pursued WhaleCore Set 2021 Promos · 60p | Core Set 2021 Promos | 60p | Rare | €0.25 |
| Pursued WhaleCore Set 2021 Promos · 60s | Core Set 2021 Promos | 60s | Rare | €0.31 |
| Pursued WhaleAlchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · 909 | Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate | 909 | Rare | — |
| Pursued WhaleMagic Online Promos · 82024 | Magic Online Promos | 82024 | Rare | — |
| Pursuit of KnowledgeThe List Tokens · STH-10 | The List Tokens | STH-10 | Rare | $0.83 |
| Pursuit of KnowledgeStronghold · 10 | Stronghold | 10 | Rare | €0.46 |
| Push Your LuckUnfinity · 224a | Unfinity | 224a | Rare | $0.21 |
| Push Your LuckUnfinity · 224b | Unfinity | 224b | Rare | $0.19 |
| PutrefaxScars of Mirrodin · 126 | Scars of Mirrodin | 126 | Rare | €0.34 |
| PutrefyMagic Player Rewards 2006 · 5 | Magic Player Rewards 2006 | 5 | Rare | €0.92 |
| PutrefyStrixhaven Mystical Archive · 63 | Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 63 | Rare | $0.48 |
| PutrefyStrixhaven Mystical Archive · 126 | Strixhaven Mystical Archive | 126 | Rare | $1.37 |
| PutrefySecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2299 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2299 | Rare | $2.06 |
| Putrefying RotboarAlchemy: Bloomburrow · 10 | Alchemy: Bloomburrow | 10 | Rare | — |
| Pygmy AllosaurusIce Age · 257 | Ice Age | 257 | Rare | €0.99 |
| Pygmy HippoVisions · 133 | Visions | 133 | Rare | €0.93 |
| Pyramid of the PantheonAmonkhet · 235 | Amonkhet | 235 | Rare | €0.23 |
| Pyramid of the PantheonAmonkhet Promos · 235s | Amonkhet Promos | 235s | Rare | €0.93 |
| PyramidsArabian Nights · 67 | Arabian Nights | 67 | Rare | €52.76 |
| Pyre of HeroesKaldheim · 241 | Kaldheim | 241 | Rare | $1.53 |
| Pyre of HeroesKaldheim · 370 | Kaldheim | 370 | Rare | €2.38 |
| Pyre of HeroesKaldheim Promos · 241p | Kaldheim Promos | 241p | Rare | €1.92 |
| Pyre of HeroesKaldheim Promos · 241s | Kaldheim Promos | 241s | Rare | €1.95 |
| Pyre of HeroesMagic Online Promos · 88394 | Magic Online Promos | 88394 | Rare | — |
| Pyre Rhymer // Molten TideReality Fracture · 91 | Reality Fracture | 91 | Rare | €0.33 |
| Pyre Rhymer // Molten TideReality Fracture · 429 | Reality Fracture | 429 | Rare | €0.30 |