| Icingdeath, Frost TyrantAdventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos · 20s | Adventures in the Forgotten Realms Promos | 20s | Mythic Rare | €2.73 |
| Icingdeath, Frost TyrantSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 1012b | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 1012b | Mythic Rare | €7.76 |
| Icingdeath, Frost TyrantMagic Online Promos · 92620 | Magic Online Promos | 92620 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Idyllic TutorSpecial Guests · 129 | Special Guests | 129 | Mythic Rare | €8.21 |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperCommander 2016 · 32 | Commander 2016 | 32 | Mythic Rare | $1.23 |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperCommander Anthology Volume II · 11 | Commander Anthology Volume II | 11 | Mythic Rare | €1.44 |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperCommander Legends · 519 | Commander Legends | 519 | Mythic Rare | €2.30 |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperTarkir: Dragonstorm Commander · 100 | Tarkir: Dragonstorm Commander | 100 | Mythic Rare | $0.58 |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperThe List Tokens · CM2-11 | The List Tokens | CM2-11 | Mythic Rare | $0.39 |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperTreasure Chest · 58 | Treasure Chest | 58 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Ikra Shidiqi, the UsurperMagic Online Promos · 86158 | Magic Online Promos | 86158 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarWar of the Spark Promos · 133s | War of the Spark Promos | 133s | Mythic Rare | €8.26 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarRavnica Remastered · 113 | Ravnica Remastered | 113 | Mythic Rare | €6.78 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarRavnica Remastered · 334 | Ravnica Remastered | 334 | Mythic Rare | €7.45 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarRavnica Remastered · 334z | Ravnica Remastered | 334z | Mythic Rare | $274.01 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarRavnica Remastered · 429 | Ravnica Remastered | 429 | Mythic Rare | $10.78 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 318 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 318 | Mythic Rare | €11.15 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarWar of the Spark · 133 | War of the Spark | 133 | Mythic Rare | €5.95 |
| Ilharg, the Raze-BoarSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2402 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2402 | Mythic Rare | $2.33 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesDominaria United Commander · 154 | Dominaria United Commander | 154 | Mythic Rare | €0.27 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesIkoria: Lair of Behemoths · 190 | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths | 190 | Mythic Rare | $0.48 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesIkoria: Lair of Behemoths · 300 | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths | 300 | Mythic Rare | €1.05 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesIkoria: Lair of Behemoths · 379 | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths | 379 | Mythic Rare | €42.59 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesIkoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos · 190p | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos | 190p | Mythic Rare | €0.82 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesIkoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos · 190s | Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos | 190s | Mythic Rare | €1.42 |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesMagic Online Promos · 80913 | Magic Online Promos | 80913 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Illuna, Apex of WishesMagic Online Promos · 80991 | Magic Online Promos | 80991 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Imaryll, Elfhame EliteGame Night: Free-for-All · 5 | Game Night: Free-for-All | 5 | Mythic Rare | €10.00 |
| Immolating GyreJumpstart · 20 | Jumpstart | 20 | Mythic Rare | €0.74 |
| Immortus, Master of EternityMarvel Super Heroes Commander · 623 | Marvel Super Heroes Commander | 623 | Mythic Rare | $1.68 |
| Imotekh the StormlordWarhammer 40,000 Commander · 5 | Warhammer 40,000 Commander | 5 | Mythic Rare | €4.99 |
| Imotekh the StormlordWarhammer 40,000 Commander · 169 | Warhammer 40,000 Commander | 169 | Mythic Rare | €7.23 |
| Imperial RecruiterDouble Masters · 131 | Double Masters | 131 | Mythic Rare | €10.48 |
| Imperial RecruiterMasters 25 · 136 | Masters 25 | 136 | Mythic Rare | €9.94 |
| Imperial RecruiterModern Horizons 2 · 281 | Modern Horizons 2 | 281 | Mythic Rare | €9.84 |
| Imperial RecruiterModern Horizons 2 · 314 | Modern Horizons 2 | 314 | Mythic Rare | €12.22 |
| Imperial RecruiterSecret Lair Drop Tokens · 2244 | Secret Lair Drop Tokens | 2244 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Imperial RecruiterMagic Online Promos · 91277 | Magic Online Promos | 91277 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Imperial SealDouble Masters 2022 · 79 | Double Masters 2022 | 79 | Mythic Rare | €107.39 |
| Imperial SealDouble Masters 2022 · 354 | Double Masters 2022 | 354 | Mythic Rare | €117.21 |
| Imperial SealDouble Masters 2022 · 439 | Double Masters 2022 | 439 | Mythic Rare | €119.70 |
| Imperial SealMagic Online Promos · 102253 | Magic Online Promos | 102253 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Impervious GreatwurmGuilds of Ravnica · 273 | Guilds of Ravnica | 273 | Mythic Rare | €1.65 |
| Impostor SyndromeMarvel's Spider-Man Promos · 34s | Marvel's Spider-Man Promos | 34s | Mythic Rare | €7.35 |
| Impostor SyndromeMarvel's Spider-Man · 34 | Marvel's Spider-Man | 34 | Mythic Rare | €4.64 |
| Impostor SyndromeMarvel's Spider-Man · 251 | Marvel's Spider-Man | 251 | Mythic Rare | €4.82 |
| Impostor SyndromeThrough the Omenpaths · 32 | Through the Omenpaths | 32 | Mythic Rare | — |
| Imprisoned in the MoonAvatar: The Last Airbender Eternal · 14 | Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal | 14 | Mythic Rare | €1.07 |
| Improvisation CapstoneSecrets of Strixhaven Promos · 120p | Secrets of Strixhaven Promos | 120p | Mythic Rare | €10.18 |
| Improvisation CapstoneSecrets of Strixhaven · 120 | Secrets of Strixhaven | 120 | Mythic Rare | $9.68 |