| Icy ManipulatorDominaria · 219 | Dominaria | 219 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Icy ManipulatorDominaria Remastered · 380 | Dominaria Remastered | 380 | Uncommon | €0.10 |
| Icy ManipulatorFriday Night Magic 2005 · 12 | Friday Night Magic 2005 | 12 | Rare | €2.23 |
| Icy ManipulatorIce Age · 322 | Ice Age | 322 | Uncommon | €1.01 |
| Icy ManipulatorLimited Edition Alpha · 248 | Limited Edition Alpha | 248 | Uncommon | $745.47 |
| Icy ManipulatorLimited Edition Beta · 249 | Limited Edition Beta | 249 | Uncommon | €188.80 |
| Icy ManipulatorMirrodin · 186 | Mirrodin | 186 | Uncommon | €0.08 |
| Icy ManipulatorOversized League Prizes · 6 | Oversized League Prizes | 6 | Rare | — |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · bl322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | bl322 | Uncommon | €0.32 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · et322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | et322 | Uncommon | €0.26 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · mj322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | mj322 | Uncommon | $0.45 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · ml322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | ml322 | Uncommon | €0.42 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · pp322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | pp322 | Uncommon | €0.30 |
| Icy ManipulatorPro Tour Collector Set Tokens · shr322 | Pro Tour Collector Set Tokens | shr322 | Uncommon | €0.27 |
| Icy ManipulatorThe List Tokens · DOM-219 | The List Tokens | DOM-219 | Uncommon | €0.06 |
| Icy ManipulatorMasters Edition IV · 207 | Masters Edition IV | 207 | Uncommon | — |
| Icy ManipulatorMagic Online Promos · 35042 | Magic Online Promos | 35042 | Uncommon | — |
| Icy PrisonIce Age · 74 | Ice Age | 74 | Rare | $0.47 |
| Icy PrisonMasters Edition II · 50 | Masters Edition II | 50 | Common | — |
| Icy ReceptionReality Fracture · 30 | Reality Fracture | 30 | Common | €0.04 |
| Ideas UnboundThe List Tokens · SOK-40 | The List Tokens | SOK-40 | Common | $0.23 |
| Ideas UnboundSaviors of Kamigawa · 40 | Saviors of Kamigawa | 40 | Common | $0.33 |
| I Delight in Your ConvulsionsArchenemy Schemes · 17★ | Archenemy Schemes | 17★ | Common | €0.31 |
| Identify the CulpritUnknown Event · UW02c | Unknown Event | UW02c | Uncommon | — |
| Identity CrisisAlara Reborn · 81 | Alara Reborn | 81 | Rare | $0.29 |
| Identity EchoReality Fracture · 87 | Reality Fracture | 87 | Rare | $0.35 |
| Identity EchoReality Fracture · 371 | Reality Fracture | 371 | Rare | €0.44 |
| Identity EchoReality Fracture Promos · 87p | Reality Fracture Promos | 87p | Rare | €0.47 |
| Identity ThiefEldritch Moon · 64 | Eldritch Moon | 64 | Rare | €0.19 |
| Identity ThiefNew Capenna Commander · 224 | New Capenna Commander | 224 | Rare | €0.13 |
| Identity ThiefEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 64 | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 64 | Rare | €0.21 |
| Identity ThiefEldritch Moon Promos Tokens · 64s | Eldritch Moon Promos Tokens | 64s | Rare | €0.21 |
| Identity ThiefMagic Online Promos · 61559 | Magic Online Promos | 61559 | Rare | — |
| Idle ThoughtsEventide · 23 | Eventide | 23 | Uncommon | €0.17 |
| IdolizedFallout · 17 | Fallout | 17 | Rare | $1.23 |
| IdolizedFallout · 327 | Fallout | 327 | Rare | €2.66 |
| IdolizedFallout · 545 | Fallout | 545 | Rare | €7.29 |
| IdolizedFallout · 855 | Fallout | 855 | Rare | €11.97 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 · 23 | Core Set 2021 | 23 | Rare | €0.14 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 · 342 | Core Set 2021 | 342 | Rare | €0.31 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 Promos · 23p | Core Set 2021 Promos | 23p | Rare | €0.18 |
| Idol of EnduranceCore Set 2021 Promos · 23s | Core Set 2021 Promos | 23s | Rare | $0.56 |
| Idol of EnduranceMagic Online Promos · 81932 | Magic Online Promos | 81932 | Rare | — |
| Idol of False GodsModern Horizons 3 · 210 | Modern Horizons 3 | 210 | Uncommon | €0.25 |
| Idol of OblivionBloomburrow Commander · 277 | Bloomburrow Commander | 277 | Rare | €3.98 |
| Idol of OblivionThe Brothers' War Commander · 144 | The Brothers' War Commander | 144 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander 2019 · 55 | Commander 2019 | 55 | Rare | €0.30 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander 2021 · 246 | Commander 2021 | 246 | Rare | €0.50 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander Masters · 392 | Commander Masters | 392 | Rare | €2.81 |
| Idol of OblivionCommander Masters · 607 | Commander Masters | 607 | Rare | €11.97 |