Pilgrim's Eye

20 Magic: The Gathering cards are named Pilgrim's Eye, across 20 sets released from 2010 to 2024. The newest printing is from Pioneer Masters, released 10 Dec 2024. As of 17 Oct 2026, the most valuable is Pilgrim's Eye 692 from Secret Lair Drop Tokens (Foil) at $5.88 on TCGplayer and the same printing (Foil) at €4.07 on Cardmarket. The cheapest is Pilgrim's Eye 229 from Eternal Masters (Normal) at $0.04 on TCGplayer and Pilgrim's Eye 210 from Commander Anthology Volume II (Normal) at €0.05 on Cardmarket.

Every Pilgrim's Eye printing with its cheapest non-foil and dearest foil TCGplayer (USD) and Cardmarket (EUR) market price and variant

Card	Set	Rarity	Released	TCGplayerUSD	CardmarketEUR
Pilgrim's Eye 257Pioneer Masters · common · 10 Dec 2024	Pioneer Masters	common	10 Dec 2024	—	—
Pilgrim's Eye 402Commander Masters · common · 4 Aug 2023	Commander Masters	common	4 Aug 2023	$0.21Normal$0.27Foil	€0.09Normal€0.10Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 791Jumpstart 2022 · common · 2 Dec 2022	Jumpstart 2022	common	2 Dec 2022	$0.10Normal	€0.07Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 271Starter Commander Decks · common · 2 Dec 2022	Starter Commander Decks	common	2 Dec 2022	$0.19Normal	€0.12Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 263Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate · common · 7 Jul 2022	Alchemy Horizons: Baldur's Gate	common	7 Jul 2022	—	—
Pilgrim's Eye 333Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · common · 10 Jun 2022	Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate	common	10 Jun 2022	$0.09Normal$0.29Foil	€0.11Normal€0.19Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 257Commander 2021 · common · 23 Apr 2021	Commander 2021	common	23 Apr 2021	$0.16Normal	€0.07Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 332Commander Legends · common · 20 Nov 2020	Commander Legends	common	20 Nov 2020	$0.22Normal$0.31Foil	€0.09Normal€0.14Foil
Pilgrim's Eye GNT-55The List Tokens · uncommon · 26 Sep 2020	The List Tokens	uncommon	26 Sep 2020	$0.29Normal	€0.15Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 692Secret Lair Drop Tokens · rare · 2 Dec 2019	Secret Lair Drop Tokens	rare	2 Dec 2019	$5.88Foil	€4.07Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 55Game Night · uncommon · 16 Nov 2018	Game Night	uncommon	16 Nov 2018	$0.31Normal	€0.08Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 214Commander 2018 · common · 10 Aug 2018	Commander 2018	common	10 Aug 2018	$0.30Normal	€0.11Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 210Commander Anthology Volume II · common · 8 Jun 2018	Commander Anthology Volume II	common	8 Jun 2018	$0.13Normal	€0.05Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 224Commander Anthology · common · 9 Jun 2017	Commander Anthology	common	9 Jun 2017	$0.49Normal	€0.14Normal€0.06Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 229Eternal Masters · common · 10 Jun 2016	Eternal Masters	common	10 Jun 2016	$0.04Normal$0.04Foil	€0.10Normal€0.16Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 226Battle for Zendikar · uncommon · 2 Oct 2015	Battle for Zendikar	uncommon	2 Oct 2015	$0.07Normal$0.49Foil	€0.06Normal€0.35Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 262Commander 2014 · common · 7 Nov 2014	Commander 2014	common	7 Nov 2014	$0.09Normal	€0.11Normal€0.15Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 253Commander 2013 · common · 1 Nov 2013	Commander 2013	common	1 Nov 2013	$0.29Normal	€0.06Normal€0.20Foil
Pilgrim's Eye 47Duel Decks: Venser vs. Koth · common · 30 Mar 2012	Duel Decks: Venser vs. Koth	common	30 Mar 2012	$0.25Normal	€0.08Normal
Pilgrim's Eye 128Worldwake · common · 5 Feb 2010	Worldwake	common	5 Feb 2010	$0.19Normal$0.53Foil	€0.08Normal€0.50Foil

For each market, the first figure is the printing’s cheapest non-foil market price and the second its dearest foil one, each with its variant. Prices last updated 17 Oct 2026, refreshed daily at 03:00 UTC. Price information only; Dexicards does not sell cards.